Clowns to the Left, Jokers to the Right, Stuck in the Middle are Jews
My first experience with political intersectionality was decades ago. I was in New York City with my then girlfriend, Cindy, who was a graduate student at NYU. She had a second-floor apartment on the corner of Bleeker & Christopher Street – the heart of the West Village – so it was a great place to watch the annual Gay Pride Parade. Several of Cindy’s classmates joined us for the festivities. For those who aren’t familiar, this parade is quite a spectacle! As a long-time supporter of LGBTQ rights, it was exciting to see the large crowd & effusive energy. But then something changed – at least for me.
Shortly after dozens of rainbow flags passed us, I noticed several Palestinian flags hoisted high. The crowd, including Cindy’s friends, cheered wildly. I was not only surprised, I was confused: How or why would gay rights in the United States be connected with a complex, far-away geopolitical issue? Especially since gay rights don’t even exist in the Arab world – in fact, the only two Pride Parades in the Middle East are in Tel Aviv & Jerusalem! So I asked.
For the NYU graduate students, advocating for what they saw as a victimized underdog was definitional – being Progressive required supporting Palestine. And not Israel – it was a zero-sum game. They may have been well-intentioned, but the students were wildly ignorant; they didn’t know the relevant history and weren’t remotely interested in learning a competing narrative. And this was the Far Left 30 years ago – incredibly, it’s gotten worse since.
Recently, I listened to an interview with Stanford University student Taryn Thomas as she recounted her experience being drawn into the anti-Israel rallies that took over her........





















Toi Staff
Penny S. Tee
Gideon Levy
Sabine Sterk
Mark Travers Ph.d
Gilles Touboul
John Nosta
Daniel Orenstein