JEWISH MOMENTS IN THE LAND OF ISRAEL

Conversos is Safed: Locking the Door or Opening It?

The arrival of Conversos in Safed and other towns of the Land of Israel posed urgent questions for Jewish society. Were they to be embraced as ba‘alei teshuvah, “penitents” in the ancestral land, or treated with suspicion and kept at arm’s length? Sources from sixteenth‑century Safed reveal two broad approaches. One sought, sometimes creatively, to re‑admit these Jews to full communal life. The other, rooted in halachic and moral concerns, placed significant obstacles in their path and reinforced their separation.

Locking the Door or Opening It: this was the question the sages of Safed had to struggle with when relating to the numerous contingents of conversos from Spain and Portugal arriving to the Holy Land. The overall picture is of a community torn between empathy and fear, between the desire to reopen the door to Jews emerging from the darkness of the Inquisition and the anxiety that doing so might compromise halachic categories or communal integrity.

R. yaakov Berab, Safed’s leading halachic scholar, famously sought to renew classical semichah and ultimately a Sanhedrin. Among his motivations was the need for a proper judicial framework to address grave sins, including conversion to Christianity, often treated as analogous to offenses punishable by karet, that is, being spiritually being cut off from the Jewish people.  Only a Sanhedrin could administer the traditional thirty‑nine lashes used as a formal act of atonement.  R. Berab’s initiative was never fully........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)