JEWISH MOMENTS IN THE LAND OF ISRAEL 

Beitar in Memory: Rabbinic Lament and the Legacy of the Fall

The fall of Beitar, the Mishnah states occurred on the 9th of Av, passed from history into memory. Rabbinic literature, above all Lamentations Rabbah and the Jerusalem Talmud, recast the catastrophe in theological language: rivers of blood, the unburied dead, the leader slain by a serpent. In doing so, the rabbis transformed defeat into lament, folded Beitar into the calendar of mourning, and read the disaster as both the wages of sin and the memory of a lost sovereignty.

Rabbinic tradition transformed the fall of Beitar into legend and lament. The Jerusalem Talmud and Lamentations Rabbah recount, in heightened language, the siege of the city: the vast armies of Hadrian, the rivers of blood said to flow to the sea, the refusal to bury the slain until a later emperor relented. These stories, of Hadrian slaying “eighty myriads” at Beitar, of Bar Kochba telling heaven neither to help nor hinder his fighters, are not sober history but memory refracted through grief. They reveal how deeply the disaster cut, and how the rabbis sought to explain catastrophe as the wages of sin, even as they preserved the memory of resistance. In their hands........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)