The Only Man Not in the Room
When a casualty notification officer knocks on a door in Israel and tells parents that their son has been killed, she now tells them one thing more: that his sperm can be retrieved and that there are only hours to decide.
What appears at the door is not a grandchild. It is the possibility of one. For most people the thought is close to unthinkable, and yet it is hard to name what exactly is unthinkable about it.
Not that a child may be born after his father’s death: a woman widowed while pregnant is a familiar figure here. Not that bereaved parents want something of their son to continue; that wish is old enough to have shaped villages, foundations, and street names. Not even the medicine, practiced here for more than twenty years.
What is unusual is the sequence of decisions that begins at the door. Within hours, someone must decide whether sperm may be taken from the man’s body and preserved at his family’s request. Years later, someone may decide whether it can be used to conceive a child, a question that falls, in the end, to a family court. Israel treats these as separate matters, for good reason. The only person absent from both is the man they concern.
The scale is no longer small. Sperm has been retrieved from roughly a quarter of the soldiers and security personnel killed in this war: 253 men as of April 2026, 82 percent at a parent’s request. Before October 7 a parent needed a court order even to ask; a special order removed that requirement in the war’s first week. Only two families have so far been granted permission to conceive. What exists at scale is held........
