menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

She Left Us Only This: The Forgotten Essay of Virginia Clark

24 0
yesterday

We know practically nothing about her.

What we do know comes from a single document written in 1947. She came from a family that included impressive Torah scholars. She was deeply influenced by a man born and baptized a Catholic, raised for the priesthood, yet who spent his adult life studying and teaching traditional Jewish texts, including the Mishnah and Kabbalah. And she found a beacon of light in a fledgling organization dedicated to promoting the ideals of the Decalogue faith on a universal basis.

Still, she was haunted by a tragic past.

Her name was Virginia Clark. Soon after the end of World War II, she earned a master’s degree from Columbia University. In 1947, she wrote a short essay reflecting on Israel’s role on the world stage, offering examples of a faith deeply internalized—lived, not merely inherited. Beneath her thoughtful observations lay something more personal: a quiet but unmistakable struggle shaped by painful memories of loss. Her essay included a dedication page.

And that is all we know about her.

While combing through the vast United Israel archives, I came upon her brief composition—a piece that mentioned United Israel and a remarkable individual named Aime Palliere.

Virginia Clark noted that although she had been raised in the Christian faith, her study and investigation led her back to what she called the original mother-faith of Israel. She explained her search in these words: “A mature scholar will logically go to the original source (language and people) for their facts and will arrive at mature conclusions. I use mature as not applying to age but applying to the use one makes of their mind.”

She then pointed to striking historical examples of the appeal of the Hebrew faith beyond its own people. Among them, she cited the conversion of the King of Khazaria and his subjects in the second century A.D., and, in more recent times, the conversion of thousands of Russians—whose descendants, she noted, were then living in the Kirgis steppes along the banks of the Volga and the Caspian Sea.

Then she turned to Aime Palliere.

A French writer and theologian, Aime Palliere (1868–1949) was born into a devout Catholic family and, as a young man, began preparing for the priesthood. Yet his spiritual journey took an unexpected turn—first leading him into the Salvation Army, and then, after a chance visit to the synagogue in Lyons on the Day of Atonement, drawing him toward Judaism.

Though Palliere lived by the commandments of the Torah and embraced the life of an ardent and ascetic Jew, he never formally converted. A committed Zionist, he recognized the profound spiritual significance of the rebirth of the Land of Israel and the Hebrew language, which he read and wrote fluently—yet he never set foot in the Land itself. While he regarded Orthodox Judaism as the authentic expression of the faith, he nevertheless became a spiritual guide to the Paris Liberal Synagogue and the French Reform movement. At the same time, he lectured at the Orthodox Ecole Rabbinique de France.

In 1928, Palliere published his autobiographical work, The Unknown Sanctuary, chronicling his remarkable pilgrimage from Rome to Israel. The book was later translated from the French by Louise Waterman Wise and published in English by Bloch Publishing Company in New York in 1985. In the summer of 1947, Palliere and United Israel World Union President David Horowitz exchanged warm letters following the publication of an article about Palliere’s extraordinary spiritual odyssey in the United Israel newsletter.

At the conclusion of his book, Palliere quoted the words of the noted rabbi Elijah Benamozegh of Livorno, Italy, offering a sweeping vision of universal history as seen from the divine perspective:

“Mankind cannot rise to the essential principles on which society must rest unless it meets with Israel. And Israel cannot fathom the depths of its own national and religious tradition unless it meets with mankind.”

Palliere—the French Gentile who once sought full conversion to Judaism—ultimately embraced a different calling after encountering Benamozegh. He accepted the Seven Noahide Laws, the traditional Jewish understanding of the Torah’s universal path for non-Jews.

Virginia Clark wrote her essay on June 15, 1947, in the shadow of unimaginable devastation, when the Nazi destruction of European Jewry had so recently claimed six million lives. It is the only record we have of her.

Perhaps the final words she left behind—on her dedication page—offer both a measure of closure and a glimpse of the hope she saw emerging from the deep darkness that was:

“Dedicated to the memories of my grandfather, Abraham I. Schindler of Munich, who died in the Concentration Camp of Theresienstadt; of my uncle and Hebrew teacher, Rabbi Elazar Steinberg-Rathenau of Berlin, and his wife Judith Schindler Steinberg of Munich and their three little children who died in the gas chambers of Auschwitz; of my relative Rabbi Dr. Jacob Neubauer, the spiritual leader of the Rabbinical Seminary of Amsterdam who died in the Concentration Camp of Bergen-Belsen. May the souls of these martyrs rest under the wings of the Shechinah.”


© The Times of Israel (Blogs)