menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Iran Is Not Vietnam, Iraq, or Afghanistan

42 0
30.03.2026

The Islamic Republic of Iran presents a unique strategic challenge for any potential US military ground invasion, one that fundamentally differs from America’s previous experiences in Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan. In those conflicts, US forces faced regimes or movements backed by substantial popular or nationalist support, often engaged in complex insurgencies where distinguishing civilians from combatants was nearly impossible.

A ground operation in Iran, whether a broad offensive or a limited tactical strike aimed at neutralizing the regime’s coercive apparatus, would encounter a very different result. The country’s population is largely alienated from the ruling elite, which is tightly controlled by a small ideological minority. Effective neutralization of the regime’s security forces could trigger a rapid collapse rather than prolonged resistance, potentially unleashing tens of millions of Iranians in a wave of liberation. This is not a case of nation-building against a unified adversary; it is a confrontation with an internal system of apartheid, in which a tiny minority dominates a vast majority.

Iran’s population is projected to reach approximately 93 million in 2026. Official statistics suggest near-universal adherence to Shia Islam, yet independent surveys reveal widespread disillusionment: significant portions of the population, sometimes over 50 percent, identify as atheists, agnostic, or effectively secular, and genuine adherence to the regime’s religious ideology is far lower. Decades of economic mismanagement, corruption, mandatory hijab policies, and harsh repression have eroded the regime’s legitimacy. The 2022–2023 protests following the death of Mahsa Amini, along with recurring unrest and December 2025 uprisings demonstrate that the Iranian people are not synonymous with the regime. The government does not represent the people and country; it effectively occupies........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)