Missing Evidence
The credibility of environmental governance depends not merely on the policies that governments announce but on the accuracy of the information on which those policies are based. Delhi’s latest Diwali pollution episode has exposed an alarming weakness in this fundamental requirement: the official system for measuring air pollution appears to have failed precisely when pollution reached its most dangerous levels. The issue is not whether firecrackers are responsible for Delhi’s chronic pollution.
They are one contributing factor; others include vehicular emissions, construction dust, industrial activity, agricultural burning and unfavourable meteorological conditions. The larger concern is whether citizens and policymakers are being given an accurate picture of the emergency. The Central Pollution Control Board’s monitoring system excludes PM2.5 readings exceeding 1,000 micrograms per cubic metre because its instruments are not calibrated to measure beyond that threshold.
During Diwali, however, Delhi Pollution Control Committee stations recorded concentrations exceeding 3,000 micrograms at certain locations. These extreme readings did not enter the corresponding CPCB dataset. The result was a substantial divergence between the two sets of figures, with the CPCB’s available readings........
