menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Memo to Trump, Xi and Putin: Shenzhen is not Yalta

23 0
latest

Three presidents around a table make an arresting photograph. They do not necessarily make a new world order.

The anticipated trilateral summit between U.S. President Donald Trump and his Chinese and Russian counterparts at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting in Shenzhen this week invites comparisons with Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin at Yalta. The resemblance is mostly furniture.

In February 1945, the Allied leaders commanded armies that were determining the outcome of a world war. Their negotiations concerned territories under occupation, arrangements for Germany and institutions for the peace. Even then, their agreements proved less durable than their photographs. Shenzhen brings together three leaders with incompatible ambitions, unequal capabilities and substantial constraints. None possesses the authority to dispose of other countries’ interests.

The distinction matters. Mistaking diplomatic theater for structural power encourages both exaggerated expectations and unnecessary concessions. The question is not whether these presidents would like to divide influence among themselves. It is whether they can make such a division stick.

Mr. Trump arrives politically diminished. The midterm rebuke to his MAGA-remade Republican Party has weakened claims that voters endorse his domestic and foreign policy agenda. Affordability remains an especially stubborn problem. A president struggling to sustain consent at home cannot assume that foreign governments will treat his promises — or threats — as durable commitments.

But political weakness is not national decline. America retains deep capital markets, formidable technological capabilities, abundant energy and an economy that has repeatedly outperformed pessimistic expectations. Its performance compares favorably with many of the advanced Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development economies. Trump’s difficulties constrain his bargaining authority; they do not erase American power. He can negotiate, but he cannot credibly present personal preferences as an uncontested national mandate.

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s problem is more structural. His invasion of Ukraine has become a grinding war of attrition, consuming........

© The Japan Times