Marco Rubio and the rise of the real estate ‘shadow state’

The failure of a great power usually begins with the erosion of its institutions. For the United States, that erosion is no longer a theoretical concern; it is a visible, daily reality. As the “Islamabad Process” transitioned from a collapsed mission into a frantic courier service over the weekend — with President Trump weighing a new 14-point Iranian proposal delivered via Pakistani intermediaries — the world witnessed a profound abdication of professional statecraft. By benching the State Department in favor of personal fixers, the administration has replaced the shield of expertise with the brittle vanity of the “shadow state.”

At the heart of this dysfunction is the systematic marginalization of Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Nominated as the “Secretary of Everything” to project a hawkish, traditional Republican image, Rubio has instead become a secondary figure regarding the administration’s most critical files.

Although the State Department was designed to manage complex global crises through institutional memory and congressional oversight, Trump has increasingly handed the keys of American foreign policy to Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner. Operating under the auspices of the newly minted “Board of Peace,” these are not diplomats; they are real estate developers who treat sovereign nations like distressed assets in a foreclosure sale.

The administration’s attempt to project activity by dispatching Rubio to the Vatican to “thaw” relations with Pope Leo XIV only underscores the problem. Rubio is being utilized as a cultural ambassador and religious fixer rather than the architect of national security.

This is not merely a matter of unconventional staffing; it is a fundamental misreading of what diplomacy requires. The “deal-making” logic of luxury real estate — where loyalty is the only currency and every conflict is viewed as a property to be liquidated — is catastrophically ill-suited........

© The Hill