Why did Republicans lose? Don't accept Team Trump's excuses.
Why did Republicans lose? Don’t accept Team Trump’s excuses.
Republicans suffered a major beating last week in the 2026 midterms. For this, the right can thank the Trump White House, whose approval rating has been underwater consistently since its tariff “Liberation Day” in April 2025.
It should come as no surprise that Republicans took a walloping in a cycle where many of its candidates were as unqualified as they were unlikeable — and where many of them were handpicked by a president about as popular as late-stage cancer.
A smarter party would next time nominate candidates whose entire pitch is not simply “The president said I could.”
But try telling that to the hangers-on of the MAGA movement, some of whom insist the problem was that the Republican Party did not MAGA hard enough. Heritage Foundation President Kevin Roberts, for example, believes the takeaway from last week is not that Republicans should broaden their appeal or rein in the party’s fringes, but that they were too moderate, too soft.
Roberts took exception to Republican Sen. John Thune’s (R-S.D.) remarks last week on Fox News.
“We’ve got to start talking to independent voters,” Thune said. “It’s a third of the electorate, and they went against us in four of the top Senate races in the country. We lost them by over 30 points. You cannot make that up with just Republican votes. You’ve got to be able to talk to the people out there who in general elections are going to decide it. And largely, that’s going to be an economic message. And so, we’ve got to get back to basics.”
In Roberts’s view, “‘We’ve got to start talking to independent voters’ is Swamp talk for ‘run to the middle.’” The Heritage president........
