Tackling Informal Economy With AI—Part II
Pakistan’s capacity to mobilise taxes is greatly under-explored. With a tax to GDP ratio of 8.5% along with an undeclared economy almost the size of official economy, the potential of tax collection is astronomical. With an estimated total economy twice the size of Rs1,000 trillion official economy at a modest tax collection of 16% puts a revenue of Rs32,000 billion in sight…— Haroon Khawaja, Lost FBR hits a dead end
The government needs to put in place a simplified, low-rate tax scheme to tap into the tax potential of Pakistan's burgeoning retail sector. A simplified sales tax of 4% and an income tax of 1% could net $15 billion annually—The Retail Sector's $15 Billion Tax Potential
Part I proposed a National Economic Registry capable of distinguishing taxable capacity from dependency, lawful informality from criminal activity, and taxpayers from citizens entitled to social protection. The next question is harder: how large is Pakistan’s informal economy, how many persons within it genuinely possess taxable capacity, and how much revenue can reasonably be raised through a broad, low-rate system?
The answer cannot begin with one dramatic estimate. Pakistan’s informal economy has been measured repeatedly, with markedly different results because researchers measure different things through different methodologies. Islamabad Policy Research Institute’s 2025 study estimates informality at about 59% of gross domestic product (GDP). State Bank work, using an electricity-consumption approach, has produced materially lower estimates, while currency-demand and Multiple Indicators Multiple Causes models generate still other results.1
This dispersion is not a weakness in the evidence. It is a warning against false precision. Informality cannot be observed directly like customs imports or bank deposits. Cash usage, electricity consumption, labour-market discrepancies, currency demand and structural models capture different dimensions. The sensible conclusion is that Pakistan has a very large unrecorded economy by any reasonable measure.
The labour-market evidence is less ambiguous. Pakistan Bureau of Statistics’ Labour Force Survey 2024-25 puts the labour force at about 85.6 million, with nearly 80 million employed. Gallup Pakistan’s analysis of the same survey, using the broader international statistical framework, places informal employment above 80% of employment. Even under the narrower non-agricultural definition, PBS reports informal employment at 72.5%, rising to 76.2% in rural areas and remaining 68.5% in urban Pakistan.2
PIDE’s latest employment analysis reaches the same broad conclusion from another direction. A very large majority of Pakistani workers are informal, which means economic shocks often appear as reduced income, underemployment or labour-market withdrawal rather than registered unemployment.3
A country with more than sixty million workers outside conventional formal employment cannot build its direct-tax system around six or seven million income-tax returns. Nor should sixty million informal workers be converted mechanically into sixty million taxpayers. A subsistence farmer, unpaid........
