The letter written by Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Chief Minister Sohail Afridi to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif is not merely an exchange of official correspondence over delayed fiscal transfers. It is a stark reminder of the widening gap between constitutional promises and fiscal practice in Pakistan's federal system. When constitutionally guaranteed rights begin to resemble discretionary favours, the consequences extend well beyond balance sheets, affecting governance capacity, social stability and national cohesion.

Federalism under the Constitution of Pakistan is anchored in predictability, equity and mutual trust between the federation and the provinces. The National Finance Commission (NFC) Award is the principal instrument through which this trust is operationalised. It is neither a political concession nor an administrative courtesy; it is a binding constitutional arrangement designed to ensure that provinces possess the financial capacity to discharge their responsibilities. Persistent deviations from this framework weaken not only provincial governance but also the credibility of the federation itself.

As highlighted in the CM's letter, K-P's budget for FY25-26 was framed strictly on the basis of constitutional entitlements - routine monthly NFC transfers, net hydel profit, oil and gas royalties and post-merger allocations for the newly merged districts (NMDs). These were not speculative assumptions or political gambits; they were binding fiscal obligations. Yet, actual releases have consistently fallen short, resulting in a reported shortfall of over Rs54 billion under the NFC alone.

This shortfall is not an accounting anomaly. It represents a........

© The Express Tribune