This story is part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis. 

In late February, the Wyoming House of Representatives passed a bill that would significantly change how schools, health departments and child welfare agencies interact with families. The measure would allow parents to sue municipalities and state agencies for financial damages if they believe officials have violated their parental rights. On the surface, this change may sound reasonable, but in practice, it could make public institutions far more cautious about supporting vulnerable children — especially LGBTQ students or children in unsafe homes — for fear of triggering costly lawsuits.

Wyoming already has a broad parental rights law, and conservative activists have used similar statutes across red states to challenge LGBTQ inclusion, racial equity initiatives, and policies that give minors some measure of privacy in schools or medical settings. Although framed as protections for families, these laws often end up shielding physical and emotional abuse from scrutiny and impeding efforts to address medical and educational neglect. Crucially, in Wyoming the statute requires that any government action seen as intruding into the parent-child relationship must satisfy strict scrutiny, the most demanding legal standard that courts apply. Under that test, the government must show that its action serves a compelling interest and is narrowly tailored to achieve that goal. In practice, that can make it very difficult for public officials to intervene in family matters, even when they believe a child needs support or protection.

Until now, however, the main legal remedy available under Wyoming’s parental rights law has been an injunction — a court order directing a government agency to stop unlawful actions. An injunction can halt a policy or practice, but it does not require the government to pay damages.

What makes Wyoming’s new move so consequential is that it would allow parents to sue for financial damages and attorney’s fees, adding significant financial stakes to every action that teachers,........

© Talking Points Memo