menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

To sustain WNBA growth, smash the bad habits of fandom gatekeeping

3 0
yesterday

One of us recently wore a Nirvana T-shirt, prompting a stranger to ask for a top three of favorite songs. The sheepish reply was knowing one song: “Smells Like Teen Spirit.” The stranger’s disappointment urged an appreciation beyond the band’s aesthetic, to explore their actual music.

But the exchange illustrates a social, hierarchical dichotomy: “real fan” vs. new fan.

The WNBA has struggled with tensions of longtime vs. new fans for the past few seasons. But it’s not old fans necessarily doing the gatekeeping so much as “real fans.” In fact, our recent study, “Welcome to the W,” explored how longtime WNBA fans create boundaries and restrictions to the fandom — a boundary rooted in history, player stats, and tenure. The study demonstrates how the weaponizing of historical knowledge against new fans is simultaneously a protection mechanism and a form of gatekeeping.

The research analyzed a storied WNBA message board, arguing that “real fans” were all BC (Before Clark). “Real” fans don’t just follow a league; they carry its history, struggles, and meaning.

The league sees this tension; their recent “Raising Goats” campaign attempts to bridge history while simultaneously championing a bright future. The campaign celebrates what the WNBA has been and what its future can be, centering Sheryl Swoopes amongst baby goats amid gameplay flashes of (argued) future GOATs (Greatest Of All Time) like Wilson, Stewart, Reese, Collier, Clark, Bueckers, and Cintron.

The ad states that the “GOAT” moniker is........

© Sports Business Journal