I Used to Work at the DOJ. Nobody Is Talking About the Scary New Tactic It’s Using to Target Trump Foes.
Sign up for Executive Dysfunction, a weekly newsletter that highlights one under-the-radar story about how Trump is changing the law—and how the law is pushing back—and keeps you posted on the latest from Slate’s Jurisprudence team.
Late last month, the Justice Department did something unusual, unnecessary, and capable of being explained only if one considers the political context. This sentence could refer to any number of actions undertaken by the department in recent months. However, what occurred on Oct. 23 went mostly under the radar, as political considerations clearly hijacked federal law-enforcement strategy in a disturbing new way.
I am referring to the DOJ’s charging of two former FBI officials, Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides, with, in 2023, making false statements to the House Judiciary Committee about their involvement in and knowledge of the FBI’s investigation of Hunter Biden—charges that, on Monday, a federal magistrate judge dismissed.
My focus is not on the substantive merits of the charges, the government’s exercise of its prosecutorial discretion to pursue these charges, or the close-to-an-election timing of the initiation of the prosecution. Rather, I am struck by the way the government began the case—by presenting a 27-page affidavit (sworn by an FBI agent) to a magistrate judge and thus obtaining a criminal complaint.
Using this procedure—one normally reserved for the most urgent cases—was a grossly political maneuver. This action is a troubling signal of how the DOJ might operate going forward. Most federal criminal cases start when a prosecutor calls one or more witnesses before a grand jury, establishes probable cause, and persuades the grand jury to return an indictment. After an indictment is returned, the case is set for trial. Before trial, the defendant has no right to challenge the grand jury’s probable-cause determination. Unlike in civil cases, a criminal defendant’s first chance to test the evidence itself comes before the jury.
Occasionally, prosecutors will need to initiate charges more quickly than the grand jury’s schedule allows. A grand jury, however, might convene only once a month, requiring the need for an expedited procedure. If, for example, someone detonates a bomb at the federal courthouse, there is an obvious need to ensure that the culprit is immediately detained (and thus not able to flee or cause further injury). We don’t want prosecutors........
