Gavin Newsom’s Clemency Is a Game Changer for America’s Death Penalty
Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s grant of clemency to the 548 people under a death sentence in his state is a singular event in the history of America’s death penalty. No other governor ever has come close to sparing that many lives.
Compare Newsom’s move to other governors who, in the last two decades, have cleared out their state’s death rows. In 2003, Illinois Gov. George Ryan commuted 167 death sentences and granted four pardons. Four years later, Jon Corzine commuted the sentences of the eight people on New Jersey’s death row. In 2011, another Illinois governor, Pat Quinn, commuted 15 death sentences, and in 2022, Oregon Gov. Kate Brown commuted 17. The magnitude of Newsom’s action today overshadows them all.
But it’s where death penalty sentences are headed. And as I have explained elsewhere, “Since 1977, governors in 24 states have granted capital clemency 327 times. Indeed, in only ten of the states that still retain the death penalty have governors not granted clemency during this timeframe. Three of them (California, Oregon and Pennsylvania) currently have a moratorium on executions, and another four of them have some of the smallest death rows in the country (Utah, South Dakota, Nebraska and Kansas).”
Newsom’s clemency reduced the total number of people on death rows across the country by more than a quarter. It comes in the wake of Christa Pike’s failed execution........
