menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

How to vote on Prop 40: Will a billionaire tax actually help California?

115 0
24.10.2026

Taxation, like everything else in life, is an exercise in trade-offs.

How much public good can a tax extract before it passes the tipping point into harm?

As it relates to Proposition 40 on California’s November ballot, many believe you don’t have to look very hard to find where the cost-benefit needle falls.

The measure would impose a one-time 5% wealth tax on anyone whose total net worth is greater than $1 billion as of Dec. 31, 2026, and who was a California resident on Jan. 1, 2026. After administrative costs, 90% of the revenue would go to public healthcare, while the other 10% would go to food assistance and education. The total collected could range from $28 billion to $100 billion — depending on whose math you believe. (California’s nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office estimates the state will “probably” collect “tens of billions.”)

Article continues below this ad

Whatever the total, there’s no denying that California billionaires — who by some counts control a combined $2 trillion in wealth — can afford to shoulder it.

Darien Shanske, a UC Davis law professor and a coauthor of Prop 40, called the measure a “rounding error” on the fortunes of California’s wealthiest.

For this mostly bloodless toll, Californians get relief from President Donald Trump’s “big, beautiful” Medicaid cuts and radiate with satisfaction at sending a landmark message about wealth inequality.

Article continues below this ad

Is Prop 40 so flawlessly executed that California has nothing to lose if it passes?

Opposition from the California Teachers Association, Planned Parenthood, California Medical Association, the NAACP, California Professional Firefighters and the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California suggests not.

Let’s start with the healthcare organizations, which would effectively receive 90% of Prop 40’s funds. Why are they opposed?  

Dustin Corcoran, CEO of the California Medical Association, said in an endorsement interview that there’s no guarantee Prop 40’s payload will arrive in time to backfill Trump’s cuts. The state has no existing system for assessing billionaire wealth, he said, and it will likely take years to develop one.

Corcoran cited his experience as a backer of Prop 56, which passed in 2016 and imposed a tax on vape products.

“It probably took the Franchise Tax Board 10 years of us beating them up because they couldn’t figure out how to get the tax right,” he said. “And that was a fairly straightforward thing to try and figure out.”

Even if the money does land, and that’s a big if, Corcoran argued that weak “anti-supplantation” protections in the measure will allow lawmakers to spend its revenue however they see fit — undermining one of Prop 40’s most powerful arguments, the urgency of the moment for healthcare.

University of Missouri School of Law Professor David Gamage, one of Prop 40’s coauthors, disputed these notions. He estimated that “75% of........

© San Francisco Chronicle