The Volokh Conspiracy

Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent

About The Volokh Conspiracy Editorial Independence Who we are Books Volokh Daily Email Archives Search DMCA RSS

Politics

Court Declines to Dismiss Threat Indictment Based on "I'm Going to Shoot up a Synagogue" Post

Eugene Volokh | 10.26.2026 8:01 AM

From Judge Virginia Kendall (N.D. Ill.) in U.S. v. Holmes:

After the Government filed a Criminal Complaint against Holmes on March 13, 2026 , a grand jury returned an Indictment charging Holmes with violating 18 U.S.C. § 875(c) on April 7, 2026. The Indictment alleges that Holmes operated the X account "@MapleStCapital" that displayed an American flag emoji with the statement "END The Fed." The Indictment alleges that Holmes posted on that account several statements against the Jewish community and Israel, including: "The jew will be destroyed and discarded," "From the river to the sea every Jew will die," "You inbred people will all die," and "Die Jew."

On or about March 3, the State of Israel posted a video [on the account "@Israel"] that showed a billboard with the face of Ali Khamenei along with the statement: "The world is a better place without Khamenei." In that post, the State of Israel wrote: "It's a first step towards a better world." Holmes responded to this post from the State of Israel with the following message: "I'm going to shoot up a synagogue." It is that statement that the Government alleges violated 18 U.S.C. § 875(c)….

The Indictment alleges that:

TIMOTHY HOLMES, defendant herein, knowingly transmitted in interstate commerce a communication containing a threat to injure the person of another, namely, a post on X in which he wrote, in response to a post from "@Israel", "I'm going to shoot up a synagogue", and defendant transmitted the communication for the purpose of making a threat, knowing that the communication would be viewed as a threat, and recklessly disregarding a substantial risk that others would regard the communication as a threat….

Holmes asserts that his statement "I'm going to shoot up a synagogue" is not a true threat because it lacks sufficient specificity. Holmes maintains that his post was but a........

© Reason.com