menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

How the Grammys, VMAs and Billboard Music Awards decide who wins

14 0
yesterday

Get Quartz in your inbox

Free daily briefing on global business news.

How the Grammys, VMAs and Billboard Music Awards decide who wins

Grammys vs. VMAs vs. Billboard Music Awards explained through 10 angles on how peer voting, fan ballots and chart data decide who takes home a trophy

The Grammys, the MTV Video Music Awards and the Billboard Music Awards all honor music, but each one answers a different question. A Grammy reflects what music professionals judge to be excellent. A VMA reflects how a music video fared with a combination of professional voters and fans. A Billboard Music Award, in years when the show tied winners to the charts, reflected what the data measured.

The Grammy Awards are presented by the Recording Academy, a membership organization of music professionals. Its voting members include performers, songwriters, producers and engineers. That makes the Grammy a peer award. The people deciding the outcome work in the same field as the people competing for it.

The MTV Video Music Awards start from a different place. They honor music videos. The competing work is the visual piece built around a song, not the recording alone. MTV has described its voting as a blend of professional and fan input. Fans have voted online in many categories.

The Billboard Music Awards have been tied to Billboard's charts, including the Hot 100 and the Billboard 200. In chart-driven years, winners were based on measured performance such as sales, streaming, radio airplay and touring. Fan voting has also appeared in some categories in some years.

Any comparison of Grammys vs. VMAs vs. Billboard Music Awards comes down to three inputs: peer judgment, chart data and a mix of fan and professional votes. Each method captures something different. A peer vote reflects the judgment of colleagues in the industry. A fan vote reflects the preferences of the people who cast ballots. A chart reflects measured commercial activity.

None of these systems has stood still. The Recording Academy has revised its rules over time, including how nominations are decided. At the VMAs, the fan and professional split, the categories open to fans and the voting windows have varied by year. Billboard has revised its criteria across editions of its awards.

The 10 slides below cover a selection of the mechanics behind each show. They look at who votes, how ballots move through rounds, how eligibility works, what the charts track and what the trophies look like. They are not a complete rulebook for any of the three. They explain the logic that shapes each result.

Recording Academy peer voting decides the Grammy Awards

The Grammy Awards are decided by peer voting. The Recording Academy, a membership organization of music professionals, presents the awards, and its voting members include performers, songwriters, producers and engineers.

That makes a Grammy a judgment by colleagues. A singer may be voting on other singers. A songwriter may be weighing lyrics written by a rival. A recording engineer may be judging the sound of a record they had no part in making.

Peer voting separates the Grammys from awards built on sales figures. A chart-based honor records what happened in the market. It counts how many copies sold, how often a track streamed or how much radio play it received. A peer vote asks something else: what working professionals consider excellent.

The two approaches can lead to different results. A record with modest sales can still win a Grammy if voters rate its craft highly. A commercial hit can leave without a trophy if the voting membership favors other work in its category. Neither result cancels out the other. Each system measures a different thing.

The range of professions inside the voting membership shapes what peer judgment covers. Performers can assess delivery and interpretation. Songwriters can assess composition and lyrics. Producers and engineers can assess arrangement, recording and sound. A Grammy reflects the view of people who work on the creative and technical sides of music, not the view of listeners at large.

Peer voting also keeps the general public out of the decision. Fans do not cast Grammy ballots. Audiences can watch the ceremony and follow the nominations, but the outcome rests with the Academy's voting members.

That design puts membership at the center of the system. A Grammy ballot goes to voting members of the Recording Academy, and the winners in each category come from their choices. The staged rounds that move a recording from submission to trophy and the eligibility rules that decide which releases qualify all operate around that peer vote.

How Grammy voting moves from entries to screening to final ballot

Grammy winners are chosen through a series of stages rather than a single vote. Recordings are entered, screened into categories, voted into nominations and then decided in a final round of balloting by the Recording Academy's voting members.

Entry is the starting point. A recording has to be formally submitted before it can compete. A release alone does not put a song or an album in the running. Every eventual nominee passes through this gate first.

Screening is the second step. Academy members review the submitted recordings and sort them into the categories where they belong. This step is about placement, not a verdict on quality. It still shapes the outcome. A recording placed in the wrong genre field would be measured against work it was never meant to compete with.

The nomination vote comes third. Voting members cast ballots to narrow each category........

© Quartz