Take our Authoritative Parenting Test

Find a family therapist near me

Children don't lie to their parents to be defiant.

Lying behaviors, while normal, are frustrating.

Kids lie in attempts to getting out of trouble.

Few parenting moments frustrate us faster than catching our child in a lie. The chocolate-smeared face insisting, “I didn’t eat that brownie!” The fourth grader who promises homework is finished when that homework has not even started. The teenager who gives you a partial version of their weekend plans.

It’s uncomfortable. It’s personal. And it can feel like a direct reflection of our parenting.

Before we spiral, let’s level the playing field.

Research suggests the average adult tells one to two lies per day. Most aren’t dramatic betrayals. They’re social smoothing: “I’m fine.” “Traffic was terrible.” “We’re busy that night.” We avoid conflict. We protect feelings. We save face. Much of it is automatic.

That doesn’t make us immoral. It makes us human.

And that is the lens we need when we examine our children’s dishonesty.

Kids Learn What They See

Children are wired for observational learning. If they repeatedly hear us tell small lies to get out of plans or avoid discomfort, they internalize a powerful lesson: Truth is flexible.

Young children, especially, cannot operate from a “do as I say, not as I do” framework. They imitate what they observe. If we want honesty, we must model it—even when it’s inconvenient.

The good news? Just as we teach hygiene, gratitude, and responsibility, we can intentionally teach integrity.

But honesty looks different at every developmental stage.

Toddlers: It's Not Moral Deception

Toddlers cannot lie in the moral sense of the word. What adults perceive as dishonesty is usually wishful thinking, fantasy, or an immature understanding of cause and effect.

A 2-year-old with frosting on their cheeks who says, “I didn’t eat it,” isn’t masterminding deception. They may wish they hadn’t eaten that cupcake, because they knew it would get them into trouble. At this age, kids may not connect their actions to the evidence.

Toddlers are blunt truth-tellers. Try playing hide-and-seek with one—they will proudly reveal their location.

What matters most at this stage is consistency. It’s important to focus on your behaviors as a parent. If you promise to play after dinner and repeatedly don’t follow through, your toddler won’t label it “lying,” but they will feel the mismatch. Trust is built when words and actions align.

Preschoolers: Lying as a Developmental Milestone

Between ages 3 and 5, lying can seem to appear out of nowhere. This behavior is actually a sign of cognitive growth. Preschoolers are beginning to understand that other people have different thoughts and beliefs. This “theory of mind” development allows them to experiment with shaping someone else’s perception.

Take our Authoritative Parenting Test

Find a family therapist near me

Many preschool lies are imaginative:

“My stuffed animal told me to do it.”

“There was a dinosaur in the backyard.”

Others are self-protective:

“I didn’t spill the milk. My little brother did it.”

Finally, some lies are the result of a developing brain.

If a child pushed their friend at 10:00 a.m. on the playground and their mom asked them to explain their behavior at 5:30 p.m., your child may not remember the behavior in question.

They are also remarkably bad at lying. Which is a parenting power move.

A playful response can diffuse tension. If your child claims their teacher brought a penguin to school, try leaning in with curiosity: “Really? What’s the penguin’s name?” Often, they’ll shift the story themselves.

This stage is ideal for brief, real-world conversations about honesty. When something breaks, you might say: “Mistakes happen. What matters is telling the truth so we can fix it.”

Keep it simple. Keep it calm. Avoid fear-based tactics like, “If you don’t behave, the police will come.” Even if intended to control behavior, those messages can create anxiety and undermine trust.

School-Age Kids: Morality and Reputation

From roughly 6 to 12 years old, children understand that lying is wrong—not just because they’ll get caught, but because it damages trust.

At this stage, common motivations for lying include:

Gaining peer approval

Protecting self-image

Children at this age are also deeply invested in fairness. They notice inconsistencies quickly. If you promise to return in five minutes and come back much later, credibility takes a hit.

This is also when reputation starts to matter. A child may exaggerate accomplishments to impress friends or hide mistakes to preserve their image. Rather than shaming the lie, explore the need underneath it. “What made it hard to tell me the truth?” “Were you worried about how I’d respond?” Curiosity preserves connection.

Teenagers: Autonomy and Hypocrisy Detection

Adolescents can think abstractly and understand nuanced ethics. They recognize gray areas, including white lies. Lying during the teen years often centers on privacy, independence, or rebellion. Teens are acutely sensitive to hypocrisy. If you preach honesty but bend the truth in your own life, they will notice.

At the same time, teenagers are forming their moral identity. They are deciding what kind of person they want to be. When parents model integrity—even in uncomfortable situations—teens absorb that. When dishonesty happens, approach it with steadiness rather than accusation. A confrontational tone invites defensiveness. A calm, direct approach invites dialogue. “I care more about honesty than perfection.” “Let’s talk about what happened.” Respect fuels responsibility.

Teens lie for many of the same reasons adults do:

To avoid consequences

Sometimes, frequent lying signals something deeper: anxiety, perfectionism, or fear of harsh reactions. It is important to ask yourself:

Does my child feel safe admitting mistakes?

Do I respond with shame or with guidance?

Am I expecting emotional regulation beyond their developmental capacity?

Honesty flourishes in safe environments.

How to Raise Honest Kids

1. Model honesty consistently.You need to be honest! Let your children see you decline invitations kindly without fabrication. Admit when you’ve made a mistake. Align your actions with your values.

2. Separate the behavior from the character.Saying “That was dishonest” is different from “You’re a liar.” Protect their identity while correcting their behavior.

3. Stay calm when truth emerges.If a child confesses and you explode, you unintentionally teach them to hide it next time. It’s OK to pause. Tell them, “I need a minute. We’ll talk about this soon." Then follow with: “Thank you for telling me. Let’s solve this.”

4. Use natural consequences when possible.If they didn’t study and the grade reflects that, allow the outcome to teach. Guide them toward problem-solving rather than piling on punishment.

5. Praise courage.When your child tells the truth—especially when it’s hard—name it. “That took bravery.” Reinforcement builds identity.

Here’s the bottom line: Lying is part of being human. It is not a predictor of a doomed future. It is often a signal—of development, of fear, of social learning, of unmet needs.

Your role isn’t to eliminate every fib. It’s to create a home where truth feels safer than deception. Where mistakes are survivable. Where integrity is modeled, not demanded.

When your child believes, “I can tell my parent hard things,” you’ve built something far more powerful than compliance.

You’re building character—one honest conversation at a time.

© Psychology Today