Take our Resilience Test

Find a therapist near me

One of the most common traps I see is not the setback itself, but the meaning we attach to it.

Our negative thoughts quickly turn into something like: "Why bother trying again?"

Small stumbles are inevitable, but turning them into negative identity statements is optional.

I often hear the same pattern play out in my counseling office, in relationship ups and downs, in classrooms, in the workplace, and when stepping on a scale. Someone is trying to get healthier, has a night of emotional eating, or a parent loses their patience after a tough day at work, or a child of any age gets a poor grade on a test.

When we step back and look at these isolated negative events, they often do not reflect the real picture of how we are doing in life. But within minutes, our minds, wired to always be on the lookout for danger and to react, can really mess us up if we let them.

When Overthinking Sets In, We Feel a Desire to Check Out

One of the most common traps I see is not the setback itself, but the meaning we attach to it. Our negative thoughts quickly turn into something like "Why bother trying again?" Recently, a very upset college graduate who was rejected for a job said it with even more heartfelt drama: "Why bother to rearrange the furniture on the Titanic!" In other words, a defeatist, "I am going down" mentality takes hold and pulls us down.

Just this week, an otherwise successful teen student who did poorly on a test said, "I'm terrible at school." An adult male started trashing himself before my eyes after he broke the prior night from a four-week intermittent fasting streak. He went to "I can't stick with anything!" A woman who got out of an emotionally abusive relationship said to me, "I will never find a normal, decent guy." In each of these cases, these clients move from disappointing temporary setbacks to total negative identities.

Overthinking Spreads Like Wildfire—If We Let It

When our minds reach the point where negativity seeps in, our overthinking patterns turn every small misstep into full-blown narratives about failure. Children and teens often fall into this trap, and so do many of the adults I counsel. In fact, in my book, Freeing Your Child From Overthinking, I emphasize that the real skill isn't helping your child avoid mistakes; it is about helping them avoid the negative overinterpretation of these mistakes and setbacks.

A Better Way Going Forward

Instead of jumping from a single setback to a sweeping negative judgment, we want kids and ourselves to learn a different mental shift. Here is how that subtle, yet powerful mental move sounds: "This did not go the way I wanted. What is the next step?"

What I am saying here is that people who make progress in school, at work, in parenting, in fitness, or in relationships are not those who rarely stumble. Rather, they are the ones who turn every stumble into a positive story about who they really are. Small stumbles are inevitable, but turning them into negative identity statements is optional.

Learning this distinction between temporary setbacks and letting them feed a failure identity may be one of the most important ways we can help our children, and ourselves, break free from the maddening, exhausting loops of overthinking.

Take our Resilience Test

Find a therapist near me

© Psychology Today