menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

OPINION: Think Ernest Hemingway is a fake? Then you must read The Sun Also Rises again

16 0
27.10.2026

Regional Andalucia Almeria Cadiz Cordoba Granada Huelva Jaen Malaga Marbella Sevilla Costa Blanca Alicante Benidorm Torrevieja Gibraltar Mallorca Valencia Barcelona Madrid Weather

Andalucia Almeria Cadiz Cordoba Granada Huelva Jaen Malaga Marbella Sevilla

Costa Blanca Alicante Benidorm Torrevieja

Other News Celebrity Crime & Law Education Entertainment Environment Food & Drink Business & Finance Health La Cultura Olive Press Opinion Politics Videos

Property Property News Property for Sale

Travel Travel News Olive Press Travel Learn Spanish

Contact Distribution About Us Privacy Policy

Stay Ahead in Spain. Subscribe to The Olive Press.LoginMy Account

Stay Ahead in Spain. Subscribe to The Olive Press.LoginMy Account

Stay Ahead in Spain. Subscribe to The Olive Press.

OPINION: Think Ernest Hemingway is a fake? Then you must read The Sun Also Rises again

WHEN The Sun Also Rises was published in October 1926, its harshest critic wasn’t a critic at all. It was the author’s mother.

Grace Hemingway wrote to tell her son that he had produced “one of the filthiest books of the year”.

Her book club was talking about nothing else, she said, and every page made her feel ill. (The book club, presumably, read every page anyway.)

A century later, my Olive Press colleague Michael Coy has reopened the case, though on rather different charges.

Grace thought her boy had been far too honest about the people he drank with.

Michael thinks he wasn’t honest enough: an ambulance driver dressed up as a warrior, a tourist dressed up as an aficionado, a myth that has run its course.

READ MORE: OPINION: 100 years on from The Sun Also Rises, it’s time to admit Ernest Hemingway was the biggest fake of them all

It’s a fair question to put to a man who spent his later years playing Papa to an adoring public.

But the trouble with calling The Sun Also Rises the work of a fake is that almost all of it happened.

In July 1925, a 25-year-old newspaperman went to the Sanfermines Running of the Bulls festival in Pamplona for the third summer running.

He took his wife Hadley and a gang of expat friends from Paris.

Among them were Lady Duff Twysden, a recently divorced English aristocrat with a few bob and a thirst, and the writer Harold Loeb, who had lately been away on a romantic getaway with her.

It went about as well as you’d expect.

By the end of the week Hemingway and Loeb had come to blows in public.

In the ring, meanwhile, a young matador from Ronda called Cayetano Ordóñez was dazzling Pamplona, and he presented Hadley with the ear of one of his bulls. (Michael lives in Ronda, so he may enjoy knowing that the novel’s one spotless hero, the bullfighter Pedro Romero, was also a rondeño.)

READ MORE: FROM THE ARCHIVES: Chasing American literary titan Ernest Hemingway in the hills of Andalucia

Hemingway began writing on his 26th birthday, barely a fortnight after the fiesta ended.

In the first drafts he didn’t bother much with disguises: Jake was called “Hem” and Brett was called “Duff”.

That clears up one........

© Olive Press