Conventional Wisdom: State of the Union Edition
President Donald Trump's first official State of the Union of his second term was delivered to a noticeably thinned chamber—dozens of Democrats boycotted while those who showed up attempted what Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries called "silent defiance." The speech landed in a precarious week: the Supreme Court just invalidated Trump's sweeping tariffs, polls show widespread public dissatisfaction with the economy, and the Iran nuclear clock is ticking in the background of every foreign policy sentence.
Inside, Trump played to type—praising allies lavishly, assigning others thankless tasks, relitigating the border—while Democrats struggled to find a response that didn't end up as the night's defining image.
U.S. Men's Hockey Team ⬆
The Olympic gold medalists who beat Canada in overtime drew the night's only spontaneous bipartisan applause in a chamber that can split on whether to acknowledge the time of day. They received their ovation, kept their medals, and left before the shouting started—which is the optimal strategy for surviving a Trump State of the Union.
Trump declared him a "great secretary of state" who would "go down as the best ever," which drew the loudest applause of the night. Jefferson, Marshall, and Kissinger dispatched in a single dependent clause. ¡El Caudillo del Caribe, victorioso!
The vice president was publicly handed the "war on fraud"—a no-win portfolio designed to produce congressional fights and no visible upside. It’s enough to make you wonder if he’s still confident Rubio will keep his pledge from December not to challenge him for the 2028 nomination.
Instructed House Democrats to attend and practice "silent defiance"—a strategy which turned them into the perfect prop for Trump to point at and yell: "These people are crazy!"
"Silent defiance" is a great slogan right up until the president has the microphone and your caucus has front-row seats.
Despite weeks of backlash over ICE deportation raids—which have largely nabbed people with no previous criminal convictions—tonight's speech included an extended immigration section calling Somali immigrants "pirates" and providing gory details of crimes committed by illegal immigrants. The pushback appears to have been interpreted as encouragement.
When Representative Al Green held up a sign reading "Black People Aren't Apes!"—a protest against Trump's Truth Social post that contained a racist depiction of Barack and Michelle Obama as apes—the Oklahoma Republican rushed over to snatch it out of Green's hands and then physically stood in front of him to block the president's view. In MAGA Washington, blocking a sign for the president is the new taking a bullet—and Mullin was first in line.
Originally a staple of Newsweek's print edition, Conventional Wisdom used arrows to track whose stock was rising or falling in the political circus. We're reviving it in the digital age because the problem it lampooned—hyperbole and partisan certainty masquerading as insight—has only intensified.
CW assigns arrows—up, down, or sideways—to the figures and forces shaping current events. The arrows don't predict the future or claim special insight. They capture the prevailing winds of the moment, uncluttered by tribal howling. In an era when partisan media reinforces rather than questions assumptions, CW operates from the center—skeptical of left and right alike, committed to puncturing inflated reputations and recognizing overlooked truths.
Do you agree with our editors on which way the political winds are blowing? Send us a message here.
