A shield, not a sword: what the Makkah pact’s first test reveals
On Wednesday, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman gave the Makkah alliance its clearest public definition yet. Opening the new session of the Shura Council, he said the alliance was created to strengthen regional stability and shield the region from the repercussions of tensions and conflicts. In the same address he said the kingdom was making every possible effort to de-escalate while promising to respond firmly to any attack.
That is the language of a shield, and it was delivered under fire. On 24 September Saudi Arabia said it intercepted six ballistic missiles fired by the Houthis at Taif and the Yanbu area. The Houthis went further, claiming missile and drone strikes on Riyadh and Aramco facilities in Yanbu. Riyadh has not confirmed those claims or reported damage. Five days earlier, smoke rose near Riyadh’s main airport after an overnight alert. The attacks come as Saudi Arabia has faced sustained fire from Iran and Iran-aligned groups since the Iran war began in late February.
This is the first serious test of the Makkah Joint Defence Agreement, signed on 7 August. Its central clause treats an armed attack on one signatory as an attack on all. The response was fast. The three foreign ministers met in New York to discuss activating the agreement. Hours later, on 25 September, their military chiefs met in Riyadh and discussed intelligence sharing, military coordination and capability integration. They condemned attacks that they said targeted the holy city of Makkah and civilian and economic infrastructure, an accusation the Houthis have protested against. Pakistan’s military said the three would move quickly to turn their commitments into practical cooperation.
Nothing in these statements announces a Turkish or Pakistani air campaign over Yemen or an expeditionary force. The early pattern looks defensive: integrate, harden, deter. I read that as a strategy of calibration, though none of the three governments has declared it as one.
From text to machinery
The pact is acquiring institutions quickly. At the first meeting of its Strategic Political and Defence Committee in Istanbul on 31 August, the three governments agreed to a secretariat in Saudi Arabia led initially by a Pakistani secretary-general for three years. Islamabad has since named retired Lt Gen Nauman Mahmood to the post.
The same statement did two things at once. The three governments pledged to keep supporting de-escalation and restraint as a route to peaceful resolution of crises. They also committed to deepen the cohesion of their armed forces through........
