menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Diagnosis In Place Of Reason And Feeling – OpEd

8 0
12.11.2026

The piece argues that diagnostic labels such as Alzheimer’s and autism flatten complex human stories—including Lear’s emotional turmoil and the life experiences of the elderly and the young—into sentimental medical categories that suppress reason and feeling.

It links cognitive and behavioral changes in two older people to isolation, loss of purpose and COVID-era injections, while contending that autism diagnoses can medicalize ordinary traits, generate pharmaceutical dependence and expand institutional control.

The author concludes that people should prioritize telling individual stories over applying flexible diagnostic labels that obscure social, cultural and personal causes.

At school, my son is studying King Lear. 

In a recent test, he came fifth best of twenty-two students. 

‘What was the subject of the test?’ I asked him. 

‘It is impossible to feel sorry for Lear in the first two scenes of Act One,’ he told me. 

‘What did you write?’ I asked.

‘That it is not impossible to feel sorry for Lear. Because of Lear’s cognitive decline.’

Lear, victim of Alzheimer’s disease.  

One of the richest literary outputs of human history: swallowed by a diagnosis. 

Lear’s impossible yearning for proof of love; Lear’s cleaving to paltry signs of power; Lear’s torture by impulses that define human lives by their ambiguous relation to weakness and to strength: silenced by a diagnosis.

Every spur to human reason, every catalyst for human feeling: levelled into an open plain of bedside sentiment, an Ah, Bless landscape without interest or relief. 

There are two people in my immediate circle who are a little like Lear.  

One is a woman in her seventies. She has seven siblings, near all of whom she lived until she was in her early sixties, at which point she relocated so as to support one of her children. Over six years ago, she was locked in her own house by her own government, warned relentlessly of threat from a deadly virus. In mortal dread, she submitted to being injected with an untested pharmaceutical technology and has continued to be injected ever since. Now, she no longer knows the daughter she wished to be near to.

The other is a man in his eighties. He founded a company that became a great success; for him, the looming inevitability of retirement was compounded by the mixed blessing of a son to take his place. Over six years ago, he was locked in his own house by........

© Eurasia Review