Three Free-Market Ways To Limit Immigration – OpEd
The article argues that immigration enforcement expands federal police power and that free-market advocates should instead limit migration’s fiscal costs without new enforcement powers.
It proposes a multi-year moratorium on naturalization, an end to all welfare and public benefits for both legal and illegal immigrants, and the abolition of anti-discrimination rules that restrict hiring or service based on national origin.
These steps would shrink bureaucracy and taxpayer burdens while preserving property rights and avoiding additional ICE agents or border infrastructure.
The problem of immigration enforcement has always been a thorny issue for those who prefer to reduce federal power, rather than expand it. This is why Lew Rockwell, years ago, referred to “the tragedy of immigration enforcement.” The agents of the state encourage immigrants to flood across the border and spend taxpayer’s welfare dollars. Then, conservatives—themselves reliable supporters of the regime—tell us that the only answer lies in giving the federal government more police power and spending more taxpayer money on federal police.
Many supporters of the free market reluctantly go along with efforts to use federal police to reduce immigrant populations. These opponents of immigration see how, on average, immigrants are costly for taxpayers via welfare programs, schools, and other “freebies” that go to both legal and illegal aliens. A 2023 CBO report, for example, showed that the 2021 surge in immigrant produced significantly more government spending then government revenue.
In America today, immigration is heavily subsidized by the taxpayers.
But, it is understandable why many defenders of freedom and free markets might balk at the idea of giving even more power to federal agents. After all, if there is anything that Americans don’t need, its federal agents walking around demanding to see our “papers.” We already put up with enough of that from the regime’s unconstitutional checkpoints at “border zones” that were invented after the Second World War. Many who would approve of the use of ICE as a last resort may nonetheless be alarmed by the agency’s willingness to arrest people with no warrants and no due process.
But given the costs to the native population and the longtime taxpayers, let’s investigate if there are ways to limit immigration that do not involve giving the federal government any additional powers.
It turns out there are at least three ways.
One: Moratorium on Naturalization
The first is to enact a moratorium on all naturalization. This........
