Public Housing Provides No Shelter From Shortages – OpEd
The piece attributes Spain’s housing affordability crisis mainly to artificial demand from inflationary “easy money” and restricted supply from planning, zoning and rent controls, rather than a simple shortage.
It argues that public housing fails because governments cannot perform economic calculation or assign subjective value, resulting in the wrong houses built in the wrong places while diverting scarce resources from private builders.
Only private property, free markets and capital accumulation are presented as capable of lowering housing costs, as illustrated by the historical decline in phone prices under competitive production.
A wave of protests in Spain is asking for a solution to the “habitational crisis.” What are they talking about? Basically, dwellings—both for sale and rent—are too expensive, their prices climbing continuously, pricing more and more people out of the market.
Most solutions offered consist of more government interventions, which basically means more things not allowed on the housing market or more bureaucratic processes for everything. Leftists love this approach. Those on the right see the problems with it and rightly recognize that part of the problem is the lack of supply, although they misdiagnose the problem as being only a supply issue.
And here comes public housing, which offers something for everyone, it seems. Government building and distribution of houses stops people “making housing a business” for leftists, and increases supply for right-wing advocates. They are both wrong. Public housing is a disaster and only makes things worse. Here is how.
As with any other good, housing is something that needs to be produced. In Western economies, dwellings were very basic at the close of the 18th century. Most people that moved to cities could not afford to buy as houses were extremely expensive. They rented, but also at high prices.
But, during the 19th century, this changed, as with most other goods and services. House prices declined steadily until the start of the 20th century. With the excuse of the First World War, governments started to swap to fiat currency gradually and started taxing people through inflation—the artificial creation of money—to fund government expenditures. The consequent........
