The detention of Sonam Wangchuk isn’t just a political crackdown; it’s a philosophical showdown over what constitutes true security—borders or biodiversity, corporate growth or civilizational survival

When a government jails a peaceful innovator, what is it truly protecting? The arrest of Sonam Wangchuk exposes the fault lines in India’s model of development, pitting national security against environmental security, and corporate interests against Himalayan civilizational values.

In the high-stakes calculus of modern power, an ice pyramid is a subversive object. It provides water without dams, cools the air without machinery, and sustains life without degrading the land. It is a testament to working with the grain of nature. For Sonam Wangchuk, its inventor, this philosophy of harmonious innovation earned him global acclaim. For the Indian government, it appears to have made him a threat. 

Wangchuk’s arrest under charges of fomenting unrest is the logical, chilling endpoint of a collision between two irreconcilable visions for the future: one that sees the fragile Himalayas as a frontier for resource extraction and national security, and another that sees it as a sacred, life-sustaining ecosystem requiring protection.

The official narrative from New Delhi is one of necessary pacification. From the government’s perspective, Ladakh is a strategically sensitive region, bordering both China and Pakistan. The abrogation of Article 370 in 2019, which stripped Jammu and Kashmir of its statehood and........

© Eurasia Review