menu_open Columnists
James McEnaney

James McEnaney

The Scotsman

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Is a law banning phones in schools only fuelling the latest moral panic?

Is a law banning phones in schools only fuelling the latest moral panic?

The trouble with young people today is that they just can’t pay attention, have no focus, are disrespectful, unengaged, lazy, unimaginative… I...

yesterday 10

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

If universities face cuts, principals’ six-figure salaries cannot be untouchable

If universities face cuts, principals’ six-figure salaries cannot be untouchable

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. As anyone with even the most passing interest must be aware, Scotland’s...

28.05.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Here's what a new puppy taught me about life, loss, and teaching

On June 1, 2023, in a quiet room inside an emergency vet surgery in Glasgow, my dog Fionn died after eleven years by my side. I was living, and...

24.05.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

The SNP says education matters - so why has it lost a dedicated cabinet secretary?

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. For nearly a decade, the SNP insisted that improving the state of Scottish...

21.05.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Scotland's latest exam scandal may reveal more than a single-year mistake

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. So… another year, another exam scandal? The 2026 examination period isn’t even...

14.05.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Here are some ideas to improve teacher recruitment and retention in Scotland

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. At the time of writing this article, voting has begun for the 2026 Holyrood...

07.05.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Should the Greens be under more scrutiny for the state of Scottish education?

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Let me be clear: Green MSPs haven’t impressed me any more than those from the...

30.04.2026 30

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

The exam system doesn't work - so why can't be have something better?

There is an election campaign going on just now, although you could just about be forgiven for having missing it. It may just be a result of the...

23.04.2026 30

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

It is starting to feel like the Mull School saga might never end

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. It is starting to feel like the Mull School saga might never end. To recap: a new...

16.04.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Lenzie Academy fiasco shows how Scotland’s school-building system isn't working

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. According to official figures, there are nearly 2,500 schools in Scotland, and...

09.04.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

SNP childcare promise raises big questions – the party doesn’t want to answer them

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Well there we have it: MSPs have given their final speeches of the current Scottish...

02.04.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Attainment gap claims hide worsening results in Scottish schools

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. When I’m investigating Scottish education, there’s no doubt that my...

19.03.2026 30

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Damning ASN review urges action on widening support gap in Scottish schools

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. If you are in any way interested in, connected to, or affected by the various...

12.03.2026 30

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

If teacher strikes close schools, the SNP will be entirely to blame

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. "We will recruit at least 3,500 additional teachers and classroom assistants...

05.03.2026 30

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

Scotland’s children, teachers, and schools can’t afford another lost decade

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. More than a decade ago, the SNP declared it would “eliminate” the attainment...

26.02.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James Mcenaney

After Mull court defeat, bigger questions remain - but when can we expect answers?

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. As you may already know, earlier this week campaigners from the Isle of Mull lost...

19.02.2026 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

How one youth programme changed a woman's life in Scotland

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. An unfortunate reality of my job, and indeed the job of many...

13.02.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

The SQA is rebranding as 'Qualifications Scotland'. Maybe this time will be different

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. This week, the latest stage in the rebrand of the SQA got underway. We...

06.02.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Anxious parents deserve so much more in face of ASN unit cuts

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. Last year, officials in Falkirk Council launched a formal consultation...

30.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Teaching union calls for ambitious, big-picture thinking – too much for politicians?

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. By the time you read this, Scotland’s largest teaching union will have...

24.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

The majority of Scots have this in common: completely inadequate sex education

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. All across the country, and across various generations, people have very...

16.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Is the lack of legally enforceable ASN plans a problem for Scotland’s pupils?

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. As anyone with even a passing interest in Scottish education will know,...

09.01.2026 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

What can we expect for Scottish education in 2026? Probably more of the same.

When it comes to education, anyone can see that 2025 was yet another bruising year for the SNP and Scottish Government. A decade ago we were told to...

02.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Maybe this Christmas we can try to give some children a brighter future

So what, exactly, does a specialist education journalist write about in a newsletter that will be sent out on Christmas day, and which also doubles as...

26.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Would you send your child to a ‘significant risk of life’ school?

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. Would you send your child to a school that had been described as...

19.12.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

The SNP cannot spin and pull wool over the eyes of these education statistics

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. ​Over the past ten years I have, on occasion, criticised the SNP’s...

12.12.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Why Scotland must make sex and relationships education mandatory to protect pupils

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. When the NSPCC says that an initiative is vital for protecting children...

05.12.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

We need to protect children... from school immigration protesters

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. If you’re reading this newsletter and take even a loose interest in...

28.11.2025 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

'Gilruth's teacher contact time proposals are just a cynical political ploy'

On Wednesday, November, 19 at precisely 2.30PM, I and other journalists received an email from the Scottish Government. The message had the subject...

25.11.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Why won't this rural council defend their education principles?

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. As of this week, councillors in Dumfries and Galloway have approved a...

14.11.2025 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

How one council’s budget options show just how bad things are for Scottish education

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. Right now, Dumfries and Galloway Council is running an open consultation...

07.11.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

I went on TV to discuss school violence – here's the only way to solve it

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. School violence was the first topic on this week’s BBC Debate Night...

24.10.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Shouldn’t communities have a say when it comes to new schools?

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. At the beginning of this week, campaigners from the Isle of Mull...

17.10.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

It might seem counter-intuitive but we must give teachers less classroom time

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. It feels like a very, very long time ago now, but back in 2021, the SNP...

10.10.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Before you shout, try actually reading the new guidance on supporting trans students

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. Earlier this week, the Scottish Government updated an advice document...

03.10.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Parents should not have to decide between an outdoor school trip or the heating bill

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. Later on in this school year, my son will be heading off for a week...

26.09.2025 10

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

What if the way Scottish schools teach numeracy is entirely wrong?

This article appears as part of the  Lessons to Learn  newsletter. A couple of years ago, I took a trip to a primary school in Glasgow to...

19.09.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Maybe we need women in charge to find solutions to sexism and misogyny?

At the beginning of this week, The Herald ran a story about Antonia Berry, who is the new rector at the High School of Glasgow. It’s not the sort...

12.09.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Our schools can't afford the ‘Centre for Teaching Excellence’ that no one wanted

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Have you heard about the Centre for Teaching Excellence? Probably not, but...

05.09.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

The additional support needs crisis risks creating a lost generation of children

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. A few days ago, a group of leading care and education charities warned that...

22.08.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

'Judge me on education': Sturgeon fails to be frank on education failures in new book

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Over the past ten years, when I’ve been speaking about the state of Scottish...

15.08.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

How would I tell students about the atrocities in Gaza? The same as every genocide

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. As many of you know, before becoming a journalist I spent more than ten happy and...

01.08.2025 40

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Why is the SQA so quiet about students cheating with AI? “We have no further comment to make.” The topic? Students using AI to cheat in their coursework.

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. “We have no further comment to make.” It’s a statement that every...

26.07.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

We need to talk more about the body image pressures facing young people Over the last academic year, the NSPCC’s Childline service delivered nearly 3,500 counselling sessions focused mainly on disorders related to eating or body image.

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Over the last academic year, the NSPCC’s Childline service delivered nearly...

18.07.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Should we cut down the length of the summer school holidays? Every year at this time, there are people who complain about the length of the school holidays, and for many this is a legitimate, annual headache.

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Every year at this time, there are people who complain about the length of the...

11.07.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

What have we learned about Scottish education over the past year? In the final Lessons to Learn newsletter before the summer, education writer James McEnaney looks back at the biggest stories of the school year.

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. To all the parents, pupils, teachers, lecturers, support staff, and education...

27.06.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

The alleged fairness of the SQA? An extra 15 minutes for a Higher English exam This week the SQA has released material reviewing its handling of the 2024 exam period, and specifically the way in which National 4, National 5, Higher and Advanced Higher qualifications were awarded after the removal of all additional support from the Covid era.

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. This week the SQA has released material reviewing its handling of the 2024 exam...

20.06.2025 20

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Scotland has built Schrödinger's Schools – succeeding and failing at the same time

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. Sometimes these distinctions are strictly political. It suits the Scottish...

13.06.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

Did the government lie to me or are they just incompetent? Either way, it’s a problem

This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter. ​In recent weeks and months – in fact, going pretty much all the way back to...

06.06.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney

How council calculations lead to busy nurseries being deemed 'under capacity' Officials want to mothball several nurseries and have pointed to 'operational capacity' figures as part of their justification. But there's a problem.

In recent weeks and months, we’ve looked at various examples of councils trying to close nurseries using a process known as mothballing. This...

30.05.2025 30

Herald Scotland

James McEnaney