Trump Warns Nation of 'Godless Communists' Following Troubling Election Results: 'They Will Kill Your People'

Global Elitism at Work: Amid Heatwave, European Commission Shuts Off AC - But Only For Lower-Level Workers

James Talarico Says Billionaires Are 'Destroying' Country. Parades Around With One Anyway.

Ketanji Brown Jackson Really Worried Judges Might Actually Apply Second Amendment In Gun Cases

Englishman Visits America For World Cup, Meets Trump: 'I Now Understand The American Dream'

New York Might Make Mamdani's City-Owned Grocery Stores Permanent

SCOOP: Ethics Complaint Targets Blue State Democrat Who Voted For Her Own Union's Agenda

Talarico Says Christianity Is 'Most Violent' Among Major Religions, Claims it Caused 'Damage' to Islam

Texas State Representative James Talarico (D) claimed in an interview this year that Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are each different seasons of the same show, with Christianity as “the most violent.” The remark extends a string of scandalizing statements by the self-described seminarian. It is most noteworthy because it was not some past comment dredged from the depths of the internet, but it came during his current campaign for U.S. Senate, during an interview for a profile published in The New Yorker on February 23, 2026.Referring to his campaign manager, Seth Krasne, Talarico said, “Seth and I talk about how Judaism is Season One of the show, Christianity is Season Two, and Islam is Season Three. I’m Season Two — the most violent season. My religion has done more damage to both of those religions than they’ve done to each other.”

Credit where credit is due: few politicians can pack theological errors together as concisely as Talarico. Here, Talarico sounds as if he is half-responding to subjects he half-learned. These comments serve Talarico’s political purposes nicely (denigrating Christianity and praising Islam both appeal to the Democratic base), but he would be too intelligent to defend the substance of these comments if ever forced to think below the surface.

The first absurd claim is that Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are Seasons One, Two, and Three, implicitly of the same show. The claim suggests that these religions are fundamentally alike and therefore equal and interchangeable. At root is the progressive belief that all religions are fundamentally about keeping behavior within acceptable limits.

Such notions may pass for wisdom in a class on Comparative Religion, which “is so much a matter of degree and distance and difference that it is only comparatively successful,” quips G.K. Chesterton in “The Everlasting Man.” “We are accustomed to see the names of the great religious founders all in a row: Christ; Mahomet; Buddha; Confucius. But in truth this is only a trick. … Those religions and religious founders, or rather those whom we choose to lump together as religions and religious founders, do not really show any........

© Western Journalism