menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Backstory: Only Information Can Help Breach the Wall of Subterfuge the ECI Has Built to Disenfranchise Millions

36 0
31.10.2026

Listen to this article:

It has been exactly 21 years since India got itself the Right to Information law. I remember the exuberance of that moment, with the world acknowledging it as an exemplar of how democracy can be deepened. It was argued that it is only through access to information can Article 19(1)a (the right to freedom of expression) achieve full fruition. It also became a crucial tool for investigative journalism.

This government’s attempts to undermine it began right from the days Narendra Modi was campaigning to become prime minister in 2014.  His contempt for the law came across in a question he put to election crowds: ‘Has the RTI given you something for your stomach?’ The years in power only added to the vexation, as intrepid transparency activists deployed the RTI to pose searching questions, including the earliest ones on what became of the promised Rs 15 lakh that were to come into people’s bank accounts and where the PM’s graduation certificate was. These queries were rebuffed through various stratagems. Queries on the PM Cares Fund, for instance, were fobbed off with the lofty claim that it was a “public charitable trust” not a “public authority”, and therefore cannot invite RTI scrutiny.

But it was not just individual responses, the larger effort was to render the law ineffectual. The edifice envisaged in the 2005 law to ensure its smooth functioning was systematically undermined, with Central and state information commissions kept understaffed and headless, leading to inevitable delays in responses. By 2019, the Union government moved to tighten its grip on the institution by altering the terms of employment for information commissioners, whether at the state or Central level, to ensure they remained loyal to their political bosses. 

Information Commissioners were now required to follow directives issued by the PMO which often translated to the outright denial of the information sought. In 2020, at the height of the pandemic when crucial information was vital for people facing insufferable conditions, the Satark Nagrik Sangathan reported that 21 of 29 Information Commissions were not holding any hearings. 

In 2023-2025 came the most daring attempt at capturing and destroying the act when the Digital Personal Data Protection Act followed by the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules were passed. Now information could be denied if it fell in the realm of “personal information”. While the earlier version of the RTI law allowed access to private information if the “larger public interest” demanded it, the present law did not recognize anything like “public interest”.

So audacious was this move that even organisations owned by Modi government’s media chums like Mukesh Ambani and Gautam Adani came together as part of a 21-member media group, the Digital News Publishers Association, and approached the Supreme Court to strike down these provisions. They argued that the law would rob the news business of its power to investigate a story by requiring it to get permission from those sought to be investigated. As one of their lawyers, as reported in the New York Times, argued the law changed “the whole concept of what is news…If we have to ask for permission, newsrooms will shut down.”

The fact is that the RTI has over the years been immensely important to prise open many a governmental black box, whether it was the 2010 Adarsh Housing Scam or the more recent Electoral Bonds – the notorious system adopted in 2018 by this government to allow anonymous donations to political parties, most of which flowed seamlessly and ceaselessly into ruling party coffers potentially enabling secret quid pro quo deals. If the Supreme Court was forced to strike down the Bonds as “unconstitutional” in 2024, it was because of the long and patient labour of transparency advocates and journalists, many of whom used the RTI law to gain vital data.

Today the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has become the latest issue of vital public concern. Introduced in June 2026 to supposedly “cleanse” electoral rolls, it has led to 130 million Indians being disenfranchised. That the majority of these people are those unlikely to be BJP voters is just one of the intriguing coincidences of the exercise. 

Once again a black box of information had to........

© The Wire