Peter Apps’ bullish call on Operation Epic Fury mistakes a mid-trade snapshot for a final settlement

Reuters’ global defence commentator Peter Apps has declared on The Telegraph’s “Iran: The Latest” podcast that “this has been a good war for the US.” The claim is seductive in its simplicity. Three weeks into Operation Epic Fury, the Islamic Republic’s supreme leader is dead, its air force and navy are functionally destroyed, its missile inventory is reportedly declining, and the United States has reminded every capital on earth that it retains the capacity to reshape geopolitics by force. On a narrow, short-dated balance sheet, the ledger looks positive.

But any first-year finance student knows that a balance sheet is only as honest as its treatment of liabilities. And the liabilities of this war—off-balance-sheet, contingent, compounding daily—are the ones Apps declines to mark to market. His analysis reads like a trader who screenshots his profit-and-loss on a Monday morning and calls it a career. The position is still open. The tail risk is still live. And the margin calls are already arriving.

President Trump himself appeared to declare victory on Friday evening, posting a five-point scorecard on Truth Social: (1) completely degrading Iranian missile capability; (2) destroying Iran’s defence industrial base; (3) eliminating its navy and air force; (4) preventing Iran from ever approaching nuclear capability; and (5) protecting “at the highest level” America’s Middle Eastern allies, including Israel, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the UAE, Bahrain, and Kuwait. He then added, almost as an afterthought, that the Strait of Hormuz “will have to be guarded and policed, as necessary, by other Nations who use it—The United States does not!” The post read less like a strategic communiqué than a prospectus for an IPO whose fundamentals do not survive due diligence.

Take Trump’s fifth objective: protecting allies “at the highest level.” Qatar’s Ras Laffan—the world’s largest LNG facility—has been struck by Iranian missiles, with QatarEnergy’s chief executive saying repairs will take three to five years, sidelining 12.8 million tonnes per year of output and forcing force majeure declarations on long-term contracts with China, South Korea, Italy, and Belgium. Bahrain’s Fifth Fleet........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)