By sunrise on Simchat Torah, the skies over the Gaza envelope were streaked with smoke and the orange of distant fires. The sirens quieted, but the stillness that followed in Beeri and in Nahal Oz was not peace. It was the quiet after invasion. Doors were broken. Safe rooms were tested. Families clutched the handles and waited. Some whispered Tehillim. Some held their breath and said nothing at all.

We do not attempt to explain the unexplainable. We do insist on speaking within our Mesorah, our Tradition. The Jewish way allows tears, questions, and protest, yet guards the foundations of Faith. Our words here are offered with fear and with honor for those who suffered.

Beeri, known for its culture and its communal strength, lost many of its people that day. Nahal Oz, seasoned by years on the border, faced a depth of evil that defies speech. Calls went out to hotlines. Neighbors signaled each other as best they could. Local volunteers fought with what they had until help could reach them. In many homes there were long hours of hiding and of quiet questions.

Our tradition gives language for such hours. “How long, Hashem?” (Tehillim 13:2). That cry is not heresy. It is heartbreak spoken in Faith. In the Torah and the Neviim and the Ketuvim, protest and prayer live together. Moshe pleads for Israel after the calf (Shemot 32:11–14). Channah pours out her soul for a child (Shmuel Alef 1:10–11). David asks, “How long will You hide Your face from me,” and then........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)