The mass shootings began in 1941. But in the Warsaw Ghetto, death by wall, ration card, disease, and cold had already begun.

Open most accounts of the Holocaust and you will find a hinge fixed on a single date: June 22, 1941, the morning Germany invaded the Soviet Union. Behind the advancing army came the killing squads, and the systematic murder of Europe’s Jews began in earnest. Serious historians use this date. It is not wrong, exactly. The genocidal phase, the mass shooting of Jews simply for being Jews, does open here.

But to call it the start of the Holocaust is to make a quiet, profound mistake. It assumes that murder begins at the moment it becomes visible. It does not.

By June 22, 1941, the deliberate killing of Jews as a matter of German policy was already a year old. It simply hadn’t looked like killing. It had looked like a wall, a ration card, a fever. To understand what really happened, you have to hold two machineries of death side by side: the one that announced itself, and the one that didn’t.

The killing did not begin when it became visible. It began when policy made survival impossible.

The killing did not begin when it became visible. It began when policy made survival impossible.

A wall, a year before

To see this, go to Warsaw, and meet a seven-year-old girl.

My mother-in-law, Edna, was a child behind the wall that the Germans sealed around the center of Warsaw in November 1940. More than four hundred thousand Jews were shut inside a few square miles, eight months before Barbarossa, before the Einsatzgruppen became the emblem of Nazi mass murder in the East. There was no invasion here, no advancing army, no morning you could circle on a calendar. There was only the wall, and behind it a number set on a piece of paper.

And consider that wall for a moment, because it tells you everything about the method. The Germans did not........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)