Public discourse commits a basic category error: it treats Jewish descent and Jewish identity as if they are the same. They are not. And refusing to distinguish between them produces predictable distortions that harm the Jewish people.

Jewish descent is a genealogical fact. It tells us nothing about a person’s relationship to Jewish covenant, continuity, responsibility, or peoplehood. It is ancestry, not identity.

Jewish identity, in the classical sense, is rooted in the unity of the Divine, the Torah, and the People of Israel, a single, integrated identity‑system. This is not about religiosity. It is about belonging to the covenantal people.

Modernity fractured this unity. Emancipation, assimilation, and secular nationalism created a new category: people of Jewish descent who were no longer formed by Jewish covenant, community, or continuity. This was not a moral failure. It was a historical development. But it produced a split that had never existed before:

• Jewish........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)