Forgot Your Password?

New to The Nation? Subscribe

Print subscriber? Activate your online access

.nation-small__b{fill:#fff;}

Ending Aid to Israel?

Nope. It’s three-card Bibi.

This month, the United States and Israel formally launched talks to end the largest military aid package in American history. The $38 billion Memorandum of Understanding will almost certainly not be renewed when it expires in 2028. After decades in which American aid to Israel was considered untouchable, it’s clear that a big change is afoot.

At first glance, this looks like a shift away from taxpayer-funded American aid in light of the actions of the Netanyahu government, and the subsequent shrinking American public support for Israel. Over the past four years, the number of Americans who have an unfavorable view of Israel jumped from 42 to 60 percent. That number is particularly pronounced among younger Americans and on the left, although it has grown among every demographic.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu himself fed the narrative that aid to Israel is going away, telling 60 Minutes, “I think that it’s time that we weaned ourselves from the remaining military support.”

Don’t be fooled. This is three-card monte. Netanyahu is not giving up on US funding. He’s just moving the cards to make the money harder to follow.

To see why, start with what this fight was actually about. For those of us who pushed to condition US aid to Israel, cutting off the money was never the goal. It was a means to an end. The goal was—and remains—changing the Israeli government’s behavior: halting settlement expansion in the West Bank, upholding international law and the human rights of Palestinians in Gaza and elsewhere, and preserving the possibility of an independent Palestinian state.

The money mattered because it was leverage toward those outcomes—the most visible, most accessible pressure point Americans had.

For Netanyahu, and some of his allies on Capitol Hill, the end of the MOU is an opportunity to dodge that pressure while keeping American funding for the Israeli government. A new framework, described in proposed legislation, envisions replacing traditional military assistance with a new set of agreements on “joint defense cooperation” and the “codevelopment, coproduction, and mutual investment” in defense technologies. In a letter to that bill’s sponsor, Representative Marlin Stutzman, Netanyahu took credit for this framework, calling it “my plan.” The National Defense Authorization Act now being considered by the House would establish a formal US-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative inside the Pentagon.

In other words, the MOU is being........

© The Nation