States should not blindly Alabama's use of execution by nitrogen
States should not blindly Alabama’s use of execution by nitrogen
In a federal system like our own, states wanting to do something new often look to the experience of other states and imitate them. The results of such imitation are by no means certain.
“Sometimes,” political scientist David Schultz argues, “those policies are good ones, but more often borrowing from other states is a short-cut mechanism that results in policies that fail to deliver. States,” he adds, “become creatures of me-tooism, repeating and replicating policy initiatives found elsewhere without asking if in fact they work.”
That is as true when it comes to the death penalty as it is in any other policy area. History suggests that once one state adopts a new execution method, other states are certain to follow. That explains why Louisiana wants to imitate Alabama’s embrace of nitrogen hypoxia — even though the latter has yet to get it right.
Courts should not allow it to do so until it can show that it can get it right.
This is not the first time that we’ve seen this pattern of imitation in execution technologies. Take the electric chair, for example.
In 1888, New York adopted the chair as its execution method. As Professor Jürgen Martschukat says, “death by electrocution was widely perceived as an advance of civilization. It was part of the remodeled, modern world … and, as such, it was understood to give society a sense of elevation.”
Two years later, when New York became the first state to use that execution method, things........
