California's 'second look' regulations could revolutionize American prisons
California’s ‘second look’ regulations could revolutionize American prisons
On Oct. 1, California’s Board of Parole Hearings finalized a set of regulations that put the burden on the state to look at whether the people serving long sentences really need to be in prison. They say that any incarcerated person is eligible to receive a so-called Commutation and Recall of Sentence review “after completing 25 years of continuous incarceration.”
The new regulations offer the prospect of a “second look,” even to those serving sentences of life without parole, although they do not offer parole to people whose sentences preclude it.
As the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation explains, the process outlined in the new rules provides “the courts and the governor with an expert assessment of an incarcerated person’s risk to public safety before they make any prison release decision.” Incarcerated individuals who meet certain criteria “will be automatically scheduled for review.”
In the U.S. today, governors rarely grant clemency to people serving life sentences without parole. Their reluctance stems in part from the belief that they cannot safely be returned to society. The assumption has been that we should never revisit their punishment to determine what, if anything, might have changed. However, taking a second look is a rational and data-driven approach.
As a report from the Sentencing Project notes, “Evidence suggests that most criminal careers are under 10 years, and as people age, they usually........
