On June 4, one day before the federal budget was originally scheduled to be presented to parliament, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif chaired a review meeting and approved in principle a sweeping new “faceless” tax operating model. Field officers would lose the power to issue notices and conduct audits. A National Faceless Audit Wing would operate from an undisclosed location in Islamabad, allocating cases by algorithm.

A National Assessment Wing would hold hearings online. Taxpayers would receive pre-populated returns. All interactions would be digitally logged. The reform, officials said, was modelled on systems used in the United Kingdom, Australia, the Netherlands, Singapore, and India. Rollout would begin in October.

It was, by any measure, a serious-sounding announcement. It was also Pakistan’s latest.

The Federal Board of Revenue has been the subject of serious-sounding announcements about digital transformation for three decades. The Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL) was established in 1994 for precisely this purpose. Thirty years on, it was PRAL’s own systems that the June 4 announcement credited with exposing how comprehensively tax evasion had flourished on PRAL’s watch.

In April 2024, Finance Minister Aurangzeb announced at the World Economic Forum in Riyadh that Pakistan had signed a contract with McKinsey & Company for the “end-to-end digitisation” of the Federal Board of Revenue. By July, the Prime Minister chaired a four-hour review meeting at which a spokesperson for the Federal Board of Revenue declared that “the initial results are promising.” McKinsey’s fees were funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, channelled through Karandaaz because PRAL, as the Federal Board of Revenue’s own LinkedIn page noted with some candour, “hasn’t been able to produce the results.”

In August 2024, a separate Prime Ministerial task force on Federal Board of Revenue digitalisation was constituted. In March 2026, the Federal Board of Revenue launched a National Cargo Tracking System described at its signing ceremony as “a cornerstone of the broader vision for a digital and transparent economy,” with full implementation expected within three years. Thirteen months after McKinsey was hired, the June 4 announcement arrived: a new faceless model, a new hub in Islamabad, a new October rollout date.

The pattern is not incompetence. It is a charade, the repeated staging of reform to satisfy external creditors and domestic audiences while the underlying political settlement remains intact.

None of this is to say the new model is doomed to fail. Faceless assessment genuinely transformed tax compliance in India after its introduction in 2020, and the diagnostic data the government has published this time is uncommonly specific: 8,697 individuals holding a combined Rs750 billion in bank deposits reported zero income; 98.9 per cent of high-deposit individuals materially under-reported their bank flows; 80 per cent of top property purchasers systematically under-declared transaction values while maintaining active filer status.

The federal development programme, which stood at 2.6 per cent of gross domestic product in 2018, has since collapsed to just 0.6 per cent, as Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal publicly acknowledged this week

The federal development programme, which stood at 2.6 per cent of gross domestic product in 2018, has since collapsed to just 0.6 per cent, as Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal publicly acknowledged this week

The Federal Board of Revenue knows exactly where the money is. It has been known for years. The only question that has ever mattered is whether the political will exists to collect it from the people who matter. No algorithm resolves that.

Which brings us to the real crisis the budget has laid bare.

The federal government is staring at a gap of roughly........

© The Friday Times