menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Christa Pike’s Botched Execution Is a Travesty. Blame the Supreme Court’s MAGA Majority.

26 0
01.10.2026

Sign up for Executive Dysfunction, a weekly newsletter that highlights one under-the-radar story about how Trump is changing the law—or how the law is pushing back—and keeps you posted on the latest from Slate’s Jurisprudence team.

The state of Tennessee tried to put Christa Pike to death on Wednesday, in what was an embarrassing spectacle of cruelty. It was cruel because executing her decades after the crime that brought her to death row served no legitimate purpose, and because the person whom Tennessee sought to kill was not the same person whom it sentenced to death in 1996.

And just as Pike feared, her execution was horribly botched. It was stopped after two doses of the pentobarbital failed to kill her.

She is the first person ever to survive after being given lethal injection drugs.

Like her failed execution, her journey to death row was anything but smooth. Like many who find themselves there, from an early age, her life was punctuated by violence, abuse, and neglect.

On Sept. 9, the United Nations Commission on Human Rights issued a statement explaining that Pike’s execution “would mark the culmination of a trajectory of severe physical and psychological suffering marked by childhood abuse and nearly three decades of solitary confinement on death row.” That trajectory nearly reached an end point on Wednesday.

The past few days of Pike’s life were marked by a seesaw of court decisions as her lawyers tried every angle to save her life. On Tuesday, the United States Supreme Court refused to hear her claim that “the mental suffering and psychological terror she will experience under Tennessee’s lethal injection protocol is cognizable under the Eighth Amendment.”

Then the next day, when it looked like all legal avenues to save her life had been exhausted, the United States Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit granted a stay of execution so it could consider whether Pike’s desire to contest an earlier denial of habeas corpus was barred by the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act, which prohibits second or successive habeas petitions.

Her case was strong. During her initial habeas claim, Pike’s attorneys claimed ineffective assistance of counsel at her trial, because her attorneys hadn’t brought up the sexual abuse Pike suffered as a........

© Slate