menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

The fatal journalistic flaw with Nathan Fielder’s ‘You Can See Everything’

40 0
04.11.2026

Former Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes and her boyfriend Billy Evans leave the U.S. District Court building in San Jose in 2023. Holmes is serving 11 years in federal prison for fraud.

Warning: This piece contains spoilers about “You Can See Everything.”

Documentary film is our most powerful nonfiction medium, joining the authority of factual reporting to the literary license of narrative storytelling to create work of visual intensity and truthfulness. But unlike a reporter, whose use of sources may be brutish and short, the work of the filmmaker often arises from a delicate network of prolonged relationships with the subjects of a film, whose close collaboration is indispensable.

How much influence those subjects should have is a touchy question. Disregarding their perspective may be arrogant and exploitative. The film is, some would argue, their story. But heeding them too closely may cost the film its independence and leave it captured by its subjects.

Article continues below this ad

Perhaps no documentary struggles with this tension more than “You Can See Everything,” the new film about Elizabeth Holmes, whose Silicon Valley startup Theranos collapsed spectacularly in 2015 amid bogus claims of a world-altering medical technology. The crowd appeal of the Holmes story seems unstoppable: Theranos already spawned an investigative expose which has now returned to the bestseller lists, a 2022 Disney/Hulu series was ranked among the most popular mini-series on TV and an ABC News podcast has had a 900% increase in listeners since the release this month of the new film, the........

© San Francisco Chronicle