Ukraine's peace talks: Europe's strategic responsibility or its risk of becoming a spoiler?
Ukraine’s peace talks: Europe’s strategic responsibility or its risk of becoming a spoiler?
The Abu Dhabi talks have laid bare the fundamental contradiction at the heart of European foreign policy. While Washington, Kyiv and Moscow are all actively exploring a negotiated settlement, European governments risk confusing a seat at the table with the capacity to shape what happens there.
Europe’s Divided Diplomacy and the Struggle for a Seat at the Table
The Abu Dhabi talks have revealed a very awkward contradiction in European foreign policy. The European governments insist that no settlement can be reached without them, yet they have been unable to agree on who should be the European representative, what that representative should have the power to do, or whether they should be in a position to engage in direct diplomacy with Moscow at all. As Jared Kushner inadvertently admitted, “the Europeans are too divided among themselves to agree on a single negotiator.”
As Washington, Kyiv, and Moscow go through the motions of trying to work out a negotiated settlement, Europe struggles to secure a seat at the negotiation table and appoint a single negotiator.
The first round of US-facilitated trilateral talks in Abu Dhabi (10–11 Nov) resulted in an agreement in principle on a major prisoner swap, but no progress on territory or the core security issues. Moscow remains insistent that Ukraine hand over the Donbas territory it still holds, and Kyiv is not prepared to do that. According to journalist John Helmer, the inner circles in Moscow confirm that the high military establishment accepts that an agreement can be based on the present front line.
In turn, Kyiv is seeking credible assurances against a further attack. It’s a case of the parties having had nine months of no direct talks, and now they’ve got back to the table.
Europe’s chaos is more than a communications issue. Giorgia Meloni of Italy has criticised the overlapping initiatives and the lack of a single common mandate. Zelensky has been calling on the European governments to pick a representative as quickly as possible and to consult Kyiv rather than just represent an initiative.
There’s been renewed criticism of Alexander Stubb of Finland and Jonas Gahr Støre of Norway for speaking directly to Vladimir Putin. That kind of reaction only serves to underline the perception that engagement with Russia has become politically taboo in parts of Europe even when such engagement is absolutely essential to the end of the war.
Europe has........
