Does Attacking Civilian Infrastructure Weaken Or Strengthen A Hostile Regime And Population?
Any such topic is an invitation to generalize rather than think. While generalizations have their (limited) place in analysis, they are at least as likely to mislead as to enlighten us. Historical case studies do not provide universal answers; rather, it’s the details—the complexities—that frustrate our efforts to hasten victory.
Usually, this question arises when we hope to force an opponent’s surrender through airpower alone, or that airpower (or cyber-power tomorrow) will at least do the heaviest lifting. More often than not, we have pre-chosen the prescription without examining the patient. And, of course, the question presupposes that the enemy has an infrastructure of sufficient sophistication to merit attacking. Excluding the unique application of two atomic bombs to Japan, it’s difficult to find conflicts forced to the decision point primarily through airpower, whether the targets are enemy forces or infrastructure.
Perhaps the clearest triumph of airpower was the extensive use of poison gas spayed on native forces and the civilian population alike by the Italians in Abyssinia in the 1930s. Unable to respond, Emperor........
