No, Israel Did Not Compel the U.S. to Wage War on Iran
Get audio access with any FP subscription. Subscribe Now ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN
Get audio access with any FP subscription.
ALREADY AN FP SUBSCRIBER? LOGIN
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has offered a striking explanation for why the United States attacked Iran: Washington, he said, “knew that there was going to be an Israeli action,” anticipated that Iran would retaliate against U.S. forces, and therefore hit first to reduce American casualties. The formulation is not only politically convenient; it is conceptually confused. It implies that the United States acted because Israel was going to act—yet also insists that the operation “needed to happen,” as Rubio put it, regardless. That is, the argument simultaneously portrays America as reluctantly reacting to an ally and decisively pursuing its own war aims—an oxymoron that muddies responsibility rather than clarifying it.
Rubio’s framing is worth taking seriously precisely because it is likely to be repeated. In a party contesting the balance between “America First” restraint and hawkish power projection, blaming a war on an ally can be electorally useful. It allows a would-be presidential contender to have it both ways: to claim toughness against Iran while displacing accountability for the decision to fight. And historically, narratives in which the United States is said to fight someone else’s war, under pressure from Jewish actors or Israel’s agenda, have too often been a gateway for conspiratorial and antisemitic politics at home. That risk is heightened in a polarized environment and with the 2028 election cycle already in view.
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has offered a striking explanation for why the United States attacked Iran: Washington, he said, “knew that there was going to be an Israeli action,” anticipated that Iran would retaliate against U.S. forces, and therefore hit first to reduce American casualties. The formulation is not only politically convenient; it is conceptually confused. It implies that the United States acted because Israel was going to act—yet also insists that the operation “needed to happen,” as Rubio put it, regardless. That is, the argument simultaneously portrays America as reluctantly........
