From African Experience to Global IR Theory
The Kenyan-born scholar Ali Mazrui wrote extensively on international relations. All in all, he published 58 books and 679 articles (Adebajo and Adem 2024). In his writings, always lucid and infused with enthusiasm, Mazrui also sought to advance our understanding of global issues through his incisive reading of culture’s role in them. Yet Mazrui left no comparable mark on the discipline of International Relations (IR). Even in those fields and sub-fields outside the “mainstream” discipline which share a measure of Mazrui’s normative, methodological and substantive orientation, his presence is less formidable than his contribution.
IR initially engaged Mazrui in the 1960s and 1970s, first treating him as an intellectual ally (see, for instance, Bull 1977, 74; Bull and Watson 1984; Miller 1990, 65) and subsequently as an “outsider” (see, for instance, Nellis 1974, 832; Waever 1997, 4). This engagement declined considerably in the 1980s and revived from the 1990s until his death in 2014. We can therefore probably say that Mazrui’s estrangement from mainstream IR resulted principally from the discipline’s methodological transformation (Adem 2011). He was all too easily dismissed as theoretically incoherent. It appears that the contradictions he highlighted in social reality were mistaken for theoretical contradictions in his scholarship. Yet, despite the emergence of postcolonialism within the critical margins of IR, Mazrui also remained largely absent from its intellectual canon (see, for instance, Neuman 1998). Mazrui’s obscurity in postcolonialism has perhaps more to do with his perceived ideology and culture (Adem 2014). Despite this, some scholars did engage Mazrui (for example, see Darby 1997, Shaw 2017, Henderson 2018, Mittelman 2018, and Makinda and Leahy 2025). In short, Mazrui came to be regarded as a methodological “Other” in mainstream IR and as a cultural and ideological “Other” within postcolonial scholarship.
Get E-International Relations delivered to your inbox, free. As you sign up, consider becoming a paid subscriber, or make a donation, to support our work.
One thing is clear. It is long overdue to assess Mazrui’s contribution to IR or, at a minimum, ask why he remained relatively obscure in this field. The ambition of this article is nevertheless broader and more modest. It claims that when Africa’s contributions to Global IR are fully assessed one day, three works by Mazrui are likely to command particular attention. These are The Africans: A Triple Heritage (1986a and 1986b), Towards a Pax Africana: A Study of Ideology and Ambition (1967a), and A World Federation of Cultures: An African Perspective (1976).
Each of these works addresses a different dimension of the problem of global order. The Triple Heritage challenges the tendency to treat civilizations as sealed compartments; Pax Africana restores Africa’s agency in shaping regional and international order; and A World Federation of Cultures explores the possibility of global integration without cultural uniformity. Collectively, these works challenge IR’s geographical, cultural, and theoretical boundaries. Yet another significance of Mazrui’s scholarship lies in his method. He loved to cross disciplinary frontiers, juxtapose apparently contradictory propositions, and draw on diverse intellectual traditions without subordinating them to any single theoretical orthodoxy. This intellectual practice, too, is relevant to Global IR, I propose to demonstrate in this article, as are Mazrui’s aforementioned three texts.
Africa’s triple heritage, according to Ali Mazrui (1986c, 26-30), refers simply to the interplay and synthesis of the three cultural legacies that have shaped Africa: indigenous values, Islam, and Western culture. Mazrui used this framework extensively to analyze what he saw as the realities of Africa’s past, present, and future. This concept challenges approaches, such as Samuel Huntington’s (1993, 22-49), that treat civilizations as internally homogeneous and externally bounded entities. In Mazrui’s formulation, the African experience cannot be understood adequately without examining the historical interactions among the three legacies. Recognizing the historical roots of African identities in this way is not, of course, unique to Mazrui. Edward Blyden (1875, 598-615) and Kwame Nkrumah (1964) had done so in their own ways before him. Mazrui’s distinctiveness was in how he brought these legacies together, as outlined below, through a historically grounded interpretation of Africa’s cultural experience and a normative vision of what might emerge from its synthesis.
First, Africa’s triple heritage as conceptualized by Mazrui offers a relational rather than compartmentalized understanding of cultural identity. Indigenous African traditions, Islam, and Western culture are not simply three independent variables whose respective effects on Africa can be examined separately. Their significance arises from their interaction and mutual transformation in the process. In other words, African identities have developed neither in cultural isolation nor through the passive reception of external influences, but through historical processes of accommodation, resistance, appropriation, and synthesis. In this respect, Mazrui’s framework focuses on the relationships that constitute cultural identities rather than on self-contained units that later enter into contact. Relatedly, Mazrui’s idea of the triple heritage, as Errol Henderson (2018, 116-117) has noted, suggests a “diasporist paradigm which envisions world politics as an interplay of many major diasporas across a diverse and dynamic global system whose space-time is constantly in flux…”
Second, Africa’s triple heritage connects cultural interaction to the problem of power without reducing one to the other. Encounters between cultural traditions are not necessarily encounters among equals. Yet this asymmetry did not eliminate African agency. The question thus becomes: how do external forces shape African societies, and how do African societies exercise agency in return under the circumstances?
Third, Africa’s triple heritage moves beyond the diagnosis of cultural plurality towards the possibility of creative synthesis. Much of the recent debate about civilizations emphasized either their differences or the conflicts arising from their encounters; Mazrui underscored how different cultures might contribute to political and social renewal. This was not a claim that synthesis occurs automatically or that cultural contradictions can always be reconciled. It was a proposition that cultural inheritances need not remain mutually exclusive sources of identity and political conflict. As Mazrui (2004) noted in reference to Islam:
It is arguable that Islam was historically at its most creative when it was ready to learn mathematics from India, philosophy from ancient Greece, architecture from Persia, science from the Jews, and jurisprudence from the legacy of Rome.
It is arguable that Islam was historically at its most creative when it was ready to learn mathematics from India, philosophy from ancient Greece,........
