menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Honor an Election of Change. Replace Chuck Schumer

6 0
14.11.2026

Now that Democratic Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland is challenging Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) for Senate majority leader, we have a choice that lets us honor an election of change. Schumer’s supporters credit him for every Senate upset and proclaim his inevitable coronation as majority leader after leading the Senate Democrats for nearly ten years. But if he’s such a Zen master strategist, why do most of the new senators who represent so much of the party’s future almost unanimously want someone different? Maybe because they’re actually in touch with average Americans, and recognize that letting Schumer continue to symbolize the Democratic brand as majority leader insults the very desire for a different direction that powered their victory.

The new senators-elect calling for change so far include Annie Andrews, Abdul El-Sayed, Troy Jackson, Peggy Flanagan, Adam Hamilton, Chris Pappas, James Talarico, and Juliana Stratton. Scott Colom, who just claimed a historic victory in Mississippi, has questioned having two leaders from the same borough of the same city. Existing senators opposing Schumer range from Sens. Bernie Sanders and Raphael Warnock to Elissa Slotkin and Mark Warner. These senators represent diverse sectors of the party—the problems with Schumer go beyond any “progressive vs. moderate” divide. But all recognize the need for a change, and their response undercuts every argument about Schumer being key to the Democratic victories. Why kneecap them from the start by insisting on the old regime?

I saw the grassroots response this past June when I gave the opening keynote at the Washington State Democratic convention. The delegates were a diverse group of hard-working volunteer activists, spanning highly progressive Seattle districts, suburbs that recently turned blue, blue-collar cities like Spokane and Tacoma, and conservative rural areas where even identifying as a Democrat takes courage. After exploring the possibilities and challenges of the moment, I described how Schumer has dragged down the Democratic brand—with his closeness to Wall Street and relentless embrace of Israel being particularly toxic with young voters—and why he needed to go.

To succeed in 2028 and beyond, Democrats will need a strong positive vision, not Schumer’s tepid rehash of corporate-friendly Clintonism.

I then asked the crowd to try a thought experiment: Would anyone want Schumer campaigning alongside them in a critical race, whether local, state, or national? Given the breadth of delegates in the room, I expected some pushback and argument. Instead, which I didn’t expect, the entire room burst into laughter. They responded to that idea as though it was literally absurd.

So why would the Democrats want Schumer, with his 13% approval rating, as a leading spokesperson for the party? They need leaders to inspire enthusiasm, build on the election’s successes, and rebuild the party brand, not a leader who deflates momentum and sows doubt every time he opens his mouth. Here are three reasons why picking Schumer would undermine the amazing achievement of the Democratic wave:

Schumer’s strategic record is far weaker than the Democratic victories imply. Supporters say Schumer helped recruit candidates like Roy Cooper, Josh Turek, Sherrod Brown, and Mary Peltola. But all but Turek were obvious choices whom many others were also working to convince. Schumer also backed Haley Stevens in Michigan, Janet Mills in Maine, and Angie Craig in Minnesota, all of whom were problematic—in Stevens’s case, her election-eve backstabbing nearly cost Democrats the seat. Schumer’s Senate Majority PAC controlled massive Democratic dollars. But Schumer didn’t invest in Kansas until October 9, or in South Carolina until five days before the election. Schumer never invested in Louisiana, where Democrats lost by less than two points after July and September polls showed they were within four points. Nor in Florida, where Angie Nixon lost by less........

© Common Dreams