The Human Rights Campaign (HRC), long recognized as a dominant force in LGBTQ advocacy, is facing a torrent of criticism following a report by the Media Research Center (MRC) that alleges its flagship Corporate Equality Index (CEI) operates not as a neutral assessment of inclusivity, but as a mechanism for enforcing political conformity. According to the MRC’s analysis, the CEI rewards companies that adhere to a specific progressive ideology while penalizing those that prioritize free speech and diverge from HRC’s worldview-particularly on matters related to gender identity and online discourse.

The CEI is widely utilized by corporations eager to showcase their LGBTQ-friendly credentials, especially in an era where Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) scores play a significant role in attracting investors and shaping public reputation. The CEI evaluates businesses on metrics including inclusive hiring practices, employee training, health care policies, and vendor diversity. However, the most controversial component is the so-called “responsible citizenship” criterion, which can inflict a punitive 25-point deduction on a company’s score if its behavior or affiliations are deemed contrary to HRC’s values.

A high-profile example of this penalty in action is Elon Musk’s X (formerly Twitter), which received a zero score in the HRC’s 2025 ratings. The organization cited what it called failures in content moderation after Musk reversed many of the platform’s previous censorship policies and embraced a more open approach to speech. Particularly triggering for HRC was the platform’s decision to allow PragerU to release a documentary titled Detrans: The Dangers of Gender-Affirming Care, which critically examines aspects of gender transition practices. The HRC condemned the documentary, and........

© Blitz