menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

CRITICAL MASS | OPINION: Brian Wilson and Sly Stone had their demons, but never surrendered to them

3 1
16.06.2025

June 2025 will be remembered for what it took away: two of American music's most visionary architects, Brian Wilson and Sly Stone. Wallace Stevens once wrote, "The pure products of America go crazy." He was talking about the pressure cooker of idealism and disillusionment, the bright promise that so often gives way to fracture. Brian and Sly embodied that paradox -- not as cautionary tales, but as visionaries whose very breakdowns were as telling as their breakthroughs.

On the surface, they were opposites. One, a studio-bound Californian who bent harmony into cathedrals of longing; the other, a firebrand funk evangelist who turned a racially integrated band into a kinetic vision of America's better self. But their stories rhymed in the shadows. Both believed music could change the world -- until the world kicked back. And even then, they kept singing.

Their music was a second draft of American history. They wrote through the contradictions of the era: civil rights optimism souring into Nixonian paranoia, postwar innocence buckling under psychedelic revelation, California dreaming colliding with Vietnam nightmares. They didn't narrate the moment; they disturbed it, like static interrupting a clean signal.

Brian Wilson wasn't a showman; he was a listener first. A boy who sat at a piano, hearing things most people missed -- the ache under the smile, the fog behind the sun. His genius wasn't loud. It curled in the corners of a phrase, hid behind a harmony. He gave us The Beach Boys, but by the time most of us arrived at their myth -- convertibles, surfboards, the dream of endless summer -- he'd already turned toward something stranger.

That turning began early, not always by choice. Brian's relationship with his father, Murray Wilson, was a crucible of talent and trauma. Murray pushed his sons hard, managing The Beach Boys with a hand both driven and domineering -- so driven that he once sold the publishing rights to their early catalog behind Brian's back. That betrayal, like so many others, fed the melancholy in Brian's music. Even as he heard angels in the harmonies, he was haunted by the voice that told him he'd never be good enough.

"Pet Sounds" came out in 1966, but it felt like it arrived through a wormhole -- not ahead of its time, but outside of it. It understood what the myth of America refused to: that under the golden-hour glow was a sadness too wide to name. Wilson gave form to that ache, sculpting it into songs where dogs barked and flutes sighed, and voices piled on top of each other like waves crashing into memory. Where others heard chords, Wilson heard confessions. "God Only Knows," "Caroline, No" -- not songs, but glass figurines you could shatter with a breath. He made heartbreak beautiful enough to carry.

The heartbreak didn't stop with........

© Arkansas Online