Democrats’ plan to scrap the Electoral College is finally within reach. One of its architects is having second thoughts.
The context you need, when you need it
When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.
We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?
Democrats’ plan to scrap the Electoral College is finally within reach. One of its architects is having second thoughts.
In 2001, Akhil Amar laid out a creative way the US could adopt a national popular vote. Now it might happen — and he worries it could go badly wrong.
The 2026 blue wave could end up washing away the Electoral College.
In addition to winning Congress, Democrats won full control of state governments in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.
That means that a two-decades-in-the-making plan to switch our presidential elections to a popular vote system — a plan 18 states have already approved— could cross the threshold that would make it a reality.
The plan is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC). A state signing on to the compact agrees that, rather than awarding its electors to the presidential candidate who won statewide, it will allot electors would to the presidential candidate who won the national popular vote. The catch is that each state will only do so if enough other states have signed on to determine the outcome.
To clarify: There are 538 electoral votes, and it takes 270 for a majority. So if states that have 270 or more electoral votes agree to award them to the national popular vote winner — that person wins. Effectively, the country would be fashioning a makeshift popular vote system.
A decades-long plan to abolish the Electoral College may finally pay off
States with 222 electoral votes have already agreed. So if states representing 48 more electoral votes join them, the threshold is crossed. Pennsylvania plus Michigan plus any two of Arizona, Nevada, and Wisconsin would get there.
Skeptics have historically doubted that crucial swing states would voluntarily give up the power they’ve enjoyed under the Electoral College. But Democrats have turned harshly against the system — especially after the last two Republican presidents won an election without a popular vote advantage — arguing it is profoundly unfair to have the presidency determined chiefly by how a few narrowly divided states happen to break.
Early signs suggest this will be a major topic of debate for new Democratic state governments next year. Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro signaled his support for reform over the weekend, saying, “I think Pennsylvania can still play a massive role even in a national popular vote.”
So it could actually happen — the Electoral College could be effectively abolished before 2028.
And that’s making Yale University law professor Akhil Reed Amar nervous.
One might think he’d be thrilled about this, because, back in 2001, Amar co-wrote an article advancing something close to what became the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. Earlier this year, he told me he considered the idea “my baby — maybe not mine uniquely, but my baby.”
But then he used some different analogies: “This is like Doctor Strangelove. I created this doomsday machine, like Edward Teller. Well done, Amar — you just destroyed the universe!” That’s because Amar has come to believe the compact has some very serious flaws — flaws that could set the stage for a nationwide electoral disaster.
So, now that Democrats have gained enough governorships and state legislative majorities to make it a reality if they so choose, I wanted to talk again with Amar — who’s also spoken about this on his podcast — to understand his misgivings.
Why has Amar turned against the idea? What are the flaws that concern him — and are they fatal ones? Our conversation, which has been condensed and edited, follows.
How Akhil Amar started off as an Electoral College critic
You’ve been thinking about this idea of Electoral College........
