Don’t Turn Environmental Stewardship Into Climate Theater
This October marked the first anniversary of an event that baffles me to this day. On October 1, 2025, Pope Leo XIV stood beside a block of glacier ice at Castel Gandolfo and prayed over it. Artist Olafur Eliasson had brought the 20,000-year-old fragment from Greenland's Nuup Kangerlua fjord to the "Raising Hope for Climate Justice" conference.
Some commentators dismissed the scene as a “weird pagan Earth-worshipping hippie ritual,” and a traditionalist priest called it “a disgrace.” My take: the ice blessing and the Vatican's message to the UN climate summit in Brazil later last year misled believers by using bad data dressed in the language of faith.
First, let us weigh the hypocrisy. Nuuk lies nearly 5,000 km from Rome, and the organizers never disclosed how the block travelled or what the trip emitted. We do know what Eliasson's earlier ice projects cost. For his 2015 Ice Watch installation in Paris, moving 12 Greenland blocks by refrigerated container and truck released about 28 tonnes of carbon dioxide by the project's own accounting. If carbon dioxide endangers the planet as these activists insist, why burn tonnes of it to stage a prayer?
Moving past the hypocrisy that we’ve gotten used to these days, let’s look at the data that undercuts the alarm the ice was meant to sound. Alarmists have announced the death of polar ice for decades. In 2009, Al Gore told the Copenhagen summit that scientists saw a 75 percent chance the entire polar ice cap........
